By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - The vgchartz ranking game--Halo 3

darthdevidem01 on 09 October 2009
KylieDog said:
darthdevidem01 said:
KylieDog said:
Slimebeast said:

I just wanted to highlight that it's all fanboyism everywhere, sometimes open, sometimes in disguise.

Maybe stealth trolling is too strong of a word to describe it. And I never did. But still im trying to prove a point.

It can't be a coincidence that all the Sony biased members so far have given 8s?

KylieDog 8.0
CGI 8.5
FameMcSwagg 8.0
Aldro 8.0
Carl 8.9
Rick 8.2
Boutros 8.3
SciFiBoy 8.2
---------
Eight votes, Sony fan average = 8.2

If you believe there's no bias hidden in this, I think you're a very naive person.

 

I gave Metal Gear Solid 4 a score of 7.

 

I'm clearly a Sony fanboy...

Please kyliedog, stop reminding us of your flop score for MGS4!!!!!!

 

 

I'm tired of your posts like these.   I dislike MGS4, stop making an issue of it everytime it is brought up (and being on topic).  A 7 is not a flop, a score cannot make something a flop or not.

I'm tired of your posts too......they always seem so negative.

I think we should mutually ignore eachother from now on.......I see no other solution......we have no similarities & we both detest eachother.



All hail the KING, Andrespetmonkey

Around the Network
SciFiBoy on 09 October 2009

@ Slimebeast

I buy most 360 exclusives that I like, Gears of War is my fave game this generation easily so far, I also tend to get most multi-plat games on 360

Still wanna accuse me of PS3 bias?



Fame_Mcswagg on 09 October 2009
SciFiBoy said:
@ Slimebeast

I buy most 360 exclusives that I like, Gears of War is my fave game this generation easily so far, I also tend to get most multi-plat games on 360

Still wanna accuse me of PS3 bias?

I do because beast said so... he has won....lol



I'm not martin luther king. I don't have a dream. I have a plan

Sell a man a fish you feed him for a day. Teach a man to fish you just ruined a perfect business opportunity.

We didn't emerge out of the stone age because we ran out of stones. Its time to be proactive not reactive.

Slimebeast on 09 October 2009
Rickz0r said:
Slimebeast said:

I just wanted to highlight that it's all fanboyism everywhere, sometimes open, sometimes in disguise.

Maybe stealth trolling is too strong of a word to describe it. And I never did. But still im trying to prove a point.

It can't be a coincidence that all the Sony biased members so far have given 8s?

KylieDog 8.0
CGI 8.5
FameMcSwagg 8.0
Aldro 8.0
Carl 8.9
Rick 8.2
Boutros 8.3
SciFiBoy 8.2
---------
Eight votes, Sony fan average = 8.27

If you believe there's no bias hidden in this, I think you're a very naive person.

Like if told already, if the game was on Ps3 then I would've given it the score it deserved: a 7 - 7.5 . Also, maybe the reason that these people own a Ps3, is because they like those exclusives better. As the score indicates, they don't hate Halo, they just don't find it as 'perfect' as some 360 fans do.

 

EDIT: People should rate games on how they think about it, and not based on what it 'deserves'.

Well, I fully agree that it very well may be that it's in fact the Sony fans that are giving Halo 3 and other X360 games the 'real' score it deserves while the X360 fans are giving inflated numbers. But that's not my point. The point is the evergoing console war, the ranking of games, overrating your side while downplaying the competition, and the bias which I've shown statistically by the huge difference in average scores between Sony fans and X360 fans. (it's the same for all games, exclsuives, multiplatforms etc, the voting trends are clear) 

 



GranTurismoHelperMax on 09 October 2009

I'll also give this game a 9.5. The campaign was very solid and even better yet, it has a co-op option so it makes it plenty of fun to complete again on higher difficulty settings. The multiplayer is awesome and very unique for its game. It takes good communication and skill to take down the opposing team unlike many other first person shooters. Your stats are always tracked on bungie.net and its makes it one of the best features to save all your stats into one place, every match every time.

So my Pros are:
-Best multiplayer (w/ split screen)
-Forge
-Campaign w/ co-op
-Community is very stong w/ stat tracking on bungie.net




Above I'm a proud Gran Turismo fan, not a Sony fanboy, and now a proud 360 owner, but sharing xbox live accts ATM

End of 2009 Predictions (made Jan 1, 2009): My predictions were pretty accurate, the 360 was over and the Wii was just under.

Wii: 65 mil (yea I'm crazy) 360: 35 mil (its getting there) PS3: 30 mil (the slim better do well)

End of 2010 Predictions (made Jan 7, 2010):

Wii: 81 mil  360: 47 mil PS3: 45 mil


Around the Network
SciFiBoy on 09 October 2009
Fame_Mcswagg said:
SciFiBoy said:
@ Slimebeast

I buy most 360 exclusives that I like, Gears of War is my fave game this generation easily so far, I also tend to get most multi-plat games on 360

Still wanna accuse me of PS3 bias?

I do because beast said so... he has won....lol

hardly, seriosly man, I havent even played MGS4 yet, I didnt even rate it on its thread because of that.

only other game I rated in these "ranking threads" so far was COD4, which I gave 9.7 as its my 2nd fave game so far this gen and i play it all the time



Slimebeast on 09 October 2009
hsrob said:
Slimebeast said:

I just wanted to highlight that it's all fanboyism everywhere, sometimes open, sometimes in disguise.

Maybe stealth trolling is too strong of a word to describe it. And I never did. But still im trying to prove a point.

It can't be a coincidence that all the Sony biased members so far have given 8s?

KylieDog 8.0
CGI 8.5
FameMcSwagg 8.0
Aldro 8.0
Carl 8.9
Rick 8.2
Boutros 8.3
SciFiBoy 8.2
---------
Eight votes, Sony fan average = 8.27

If you believe there's no bias hidden in this, I think you're a very naive person.

I don't see how scores in the 8's can be considered evidence trolling or fanboyism.  The scores may be influenced by such but there is no way to prove it and in the end you end up standing there pointing accusingly at other members with no evidence to back you up.

Mario Galaxy was given and three and several 6's and 7's and they were counted, so I don't the point of pointing fingers at members who are entitled to give their opinion about the game.

OT: Haven't played so can't score it.

I didnt point out any individual, i pointed at the collective and I proved it through very solid statistics.



Slimebeast on 09 October 2009
SciFiBoy said:
@ Slimebeast

I buy most 360 exclusives that I like, Gears of War is my fave game this generation easily so far, I also tend to get most multi-plat games on 360

Still wanna accuse me of PS3 bias?

Sorry if my memory betrayes me but I have a clear vision of you saying u are Sony biased.

Is there a way to do a specific Google search on member posts? Ill dig it up if u wanna.



SciFiBoy on 09 October 2009
Slimebeast said:
hsrob said:
Slimebeast said:

I just wanted to highlight that it's all fanboyism everywhere, sometimes open, sometimes in disguise.

Maybe stealth trolling is too strong of a word to describe it. And I never did. But still im trying to prove a point.

It can't be a coincidence that all the Sony biased members so far have given 8s?

KylieDog 8.0
CGI 8.5
FameMcSwagg 8.0
Aldro 8.0
Carl 8.9
Rick 8.2
Boutros 8.3
SciFiBoy 8.2
---------
Eight votes, Sony fan average = 8.27

If you believe there's no bias hidden in this, I think you're a very naive person.

I don't see how scores in the 8's can be considered evidence trolling or fanboyism.  The scores may be influenced by such but there is no way to prove it and in the end you end up standing there pointing accusingly at other members with no evidence to back you up.

Mario Galaxy was given and three and several 6's and 7's and they were counted, so I don't the point of pointing fingers at members who are entitled to give their opinion about the game.

OT: Haven't played so can't score it.

I didnt point out any individual, i pointed at the collective and I proved it through very solid statistics.

solid statistics including downgrading my score by .4 that is

you also put people in the sony fan camp who dont belong there



SciFiBoy on 09 October 2009
Slimebeast said:
SciFiBoy said:
@ Slimebeast

I buy most 360 exclusives that I like, Gears of War is my fave game this generation easily so far, I also tend to get most multi-plat games on 360

Still wanna accuse me of PS3 bias?

Sorry if my memory betrayes me but I have a clear vision of you saying u are Sony biased.

Is there a way to do a specific Google search on member posts? Ill dig it up if u wanna.

In the previous 2 generations, sure, I only had PS1 and PS2 (you can find that out yeah, im sure ive mentioned before), this gen, first console I got was 360, I now also have a Wii and PS3, I own more 360 games than any other console, including many big exclusives, like Halo 3 and ODST, I play my 360 almost every day