Uncharted 2 obviously, it's a new full game. ODST will sell more though, I'm surprised to see that almost half the people I have on my friends list have it already.

lol of course Uncharted 2. Uncharted has a higher metascore then ODST I'm pretty sure and Uncharted 2 should be even better.

I predict U2 will be one of the top 5 rated games of this gen. And, like the inFamous vs. Velvet Assassin threads of yore, the OP new the answer before he even made the thread.

u2

Uncharted all day

Everyone knows Uncharted 2 will win this easily, it only really has Modern Warfare 2 and AC II to contend with for GOTY in my eyes. Batman and inFamous were good, but not Uncharted good

ODST already has 85 on Metacritic. Uncharted 2 will gain higher score easily.

This is a stupid question that everyone knows the answer. Its like me making a new thread asking UnCharted 2 vs Halo ODST, which one will sell more.

Forza 2 vs GT 5 Prologue? Forza 2 90% GT 5 Prologue 80%

Thats how silly this thread is in terms of comparisons.

Full game vs "Expansion pack"

Lets wait for Halo: Reach vs Uncharted 3 so we can have a fair comparison huh.

OP are you being serious or are you trying to pit your fave consoles September exclusive against a competitors already knowing the answer to the most predictable of answers and just waiting for an avalanche of one sided responses for you to drool over?

Cause unless you've been living under a rock for the past 2 weeks, Uncharted 2 and ODST have already been reviewed by all the mainstream sites and all gamers know which got the higher scorce and all serious gamers knew which game was going to get the higher score before either were even released!

Conclusion- Pointless question

Oh and to answer your 'question'.... Uncharted 2

Just a note here. ODST is awesome.