Scribblenauts was a sensation, it can win; NSMB Wii won't win, it is an amazing game but it won't make it, mario games aren't likely to win at all; Silent Hill: SM was praised but it doesn't has a big chance, but it has one; Japan will have the automatic FF XIII winner

I will confirm this now: Rafichamp is a Dickhead...believe me i hang out with him on PSN alot :)

In all seriousity. Scribblenauts.

Personal preferences aside, ROFL here is just wrong.  Uncharted generally scored in the high 80's, main series Mario Bros games....not sure there is one that was ever scored that low. 

I'm not saying U2 won't win GOTY but to say that NSMBW has no chance is silly and shortsighted given the heritage of the two franchises.

UNCHARTED 2 GOTY

@Xxain, im a dickhead or not playing lost panet? wdf I just hate the online

this should have been put in the gaming section if u wanted to be fair.
since the ps3 doesnt have all the game of the year choices, sorry but its the truth.
killzone 2 was good but not goty quality for me anyways, valkyria chronicles for me would be the ps3 goty , not overall goty winner though.

My votes:

Uncharted 2
MW2
Killzone 2

Hardly on FFXIII being auto-win.  You forgot a little game called DQIX which is on track to be the best selling non-Nintendo game ever in Japan.

C'mon Killzone 2 or Infamous possibles GOTY candidates?

Those games are miles away from Uncharted 2 or Demon's Souls, easily the best jrpg of this generation and I also consider it  the best game of this generation.

PD: I hate the stupid term GOTY, for me it means absolutely nothing.