Yeah good thing im not a pirate.
PROUD MEMBER OF THE PLAYSTATION 3 : RPG FAN CLUB

Yeah good thing im not a pirate.
PROUD MEMBER OF THE PLAYSTATION 3 : RPG FAN CLUB

I have never heard of anyone being caught pirating in my country in my life. As in matter of fact, we have a debate(couple of friends from around here) about that once and no one has ever heard that.
I thought murdering someboidy resulted in the death penalty.
| Onyxmeth said: This is stupid. All of those crimes include jail time (except maybe the CD theft), while the fines imposed by the RIAA are just fines. You can't put a monetary value on jail time. |
Some of those crimes come with very little jail time. You could hire a lawyer to help get you out of almost all of it, and still end up spending far less than a person who downloaded the songs. The legal system on this one is seriously fucked and needs to be redone. Penalties should exceed the benefit of the crime, but only by so much.
dsister44 said:
|
Actually, throw on your paycheck + then add the difference between minimum wage and your current or potential pay after you get out. You can enen throw on some more at your own discretion for however much you value your own personal free time away from work where you aren't really spending anything, but you are having fun. There is no way I'd be hired back as a software engineer if I murdered someone. Espescially not for a government contractor where I have to have security clearances.

| 786_ali said: Thinking about file-sharing? Don't. You'll get fined, and crime doesn't pay (unless you rob banks and/or armored cars, then it pays very well). Take it from Jammie Thomas, who was fined $2 million for downloading 24 songs, or anyone else who tried to fight the RIAA. 2. Stealing the actual CD: the fine is $2,500 3. Rob your neighbor: the fine is $375,000 4. Burn a house down: The fine is just over $375,000 5. Stalk someone: The fine is $175,000 6. Start a dogfighting ring: the fine is $50,000 7. Murder someone: The maximum penalty is only $25,000 and 15 years in jail, and depending on your yearly salary, would probably be far slighter a penalty that $2 million. |
Why are you comparing US fines for criminal behavior with the results of a civil suit?
Gnizmo said:
Some of those crimes come with very little jail time. You could hire a lawyer to help get you out of almost all of it, and still end up spending far less than a person who downloaded the songs. The legal system on this one is seriously fucked and needs to be redone. Penalties should exceed the benefit of the crime, but only by so much. |
The fines were originally about 200K and she kept fighting. The charges got worse in the next case with a new jury selection. So while those other crimes can result in little jail time, this RIAA penalty can also result in as little as $750 per song, which is the minimum. Maybe if she had better lawyers. Then again, there's good odds the charges aren't going to stick, so until this case actually ends, it's too early to say whether she's legitimately going to have to pay 2 million. Then again, these other crimes are prosecuted for the individual, while this copyright infringement case was used as an example to all of us as a scare tactic since they won't be trying any more. Basically this lady is paying for all of our sins.
For a different way of looking at it:
According to two economists at Princeton University, the value of a human life was estimated at $1.54 million seven years ago. Even accounting for inflation, from a purely economic perspective, the entertainment industry quite literally has the right to destroy your life if you are caught pirating. To top it off, even the US Department of Justice says it's fair ! All for the "offense" of downloading the equivalent of one and a half CDs worth of songs... I think it's fair to say that, in the US, the social contract of copyright (time-limited right to profit from the work before it passes into the public domain) has been thoroughly corrupted by media conglomerates. If anyone wonders why nobody respects copyright law anymore, this is why.
Super World Cup Fighter II: Championship 2010 Edition
