By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - GT5 have fake damage system.

haxxiy on 19 August 2009

Not trying to sound like a fanboy or anything, but someone with knowledge in Physics could calculate how much weight a car suspension holds and the strength of the impacts shown in the video, so we could have a rough idea if the handling should be affected in some way or not?



 

 

 

 

 

Around the Network
C_Hollomon on 19 August 2009

Who cares? It still have damage in it. I could care less if it didn't to be honest. I just like the graphics and gameplay.



yo_john117 on 19 August 2009

I really don't care one way or another, but I do get to laugh at Twingo!  I remember him saying countless times that if GT had damage, it would be true damage and not the fake bullshit damage that Forza has.  Well looks like he gets some crow :)



Carl on 19 August 2009
RolStoppable said:
Carl2291 said:
Shut up waron.

You are just jealous that GT5 > anything ever

I am sick of people like you who hate on FF XIII and The Last Guardian every chance they get.

At least i dont put down NSMB Wii (GotY 2009) whenever i see the chance to do so.

Im sick of your serious posts, and im sick of your support for PS360.



                            

waron on 19 August 2009
haxxiy said:
Not trying to sound like a fanboy or anything, but someone with knowledge in Physics could calculate how much weight a car suspension holds and the strength of the impacts shown in the video, so we could have a rough idea if the handling should be affected in some way or not?

that bumper should affect car alone, basically it should fall off after a while.

@Munkeh111, that's what i'm saying if it's not in all the cars then don't release info in fact sheet that there is damage in all cars when there isn't.



Around the Network
--OkeyDokey-- on 19 August 2009

Forza 3 has fake damage too.

Games = not real.



JOhnyBravoos on 19 August 2009
Munkeh111 said:
Not all cars have damage unfortunately, but let's wait for some direct feed footage

Fortunately all cars do have damage, and then some 170 premium cars have internal damage as well!



Carl on 19 August 2009
waron said:
haxxiy said:
Not trying to sound like a fanboy or anything, but someone with knowledge in Physics could calculate how much weight a car suspension holds and the strength of the impacts shown in the video, so we could have a rough idea if the handling should be affected in some way or not?

that bumper should affect car alone, basically it should fall off after a while.

@Munkeh111, that's what i'm saying if it's not in all the cars then don't release info in fact sheet that there is damage in all cars when there isn't.

All cars have damage, a premium set of cars have exterior AND interior damage.

Now i say it again... please... Shut up waron.



                            

XanderZane on 19 August 2009
GameAnalyser said:
waron said:

so to all those people that scream "GT5 have real damage system" i would like to point out two simple things you can clearly see from those videos:

1. damage don't affect handling AT ALL,

2. there's no car deformation AT ALL. cars are hitting walls and we can see no deformation on bumpers and front of the cars eventhoug the bumper is half on the street. car hit the wall sideway and doors are fapping all the way but still not a single scratch on them,

 

THAT'S NOT DAMAGE SYSTEM.

when car in Forza 3 drive into sand we can even see dirt on the front, we can see scratches when it hits wall, we can see deformation what it will hit the wall. GT5 on those Gamescon videos have non of those.


so the point u imply is to ditch ps3 for 360 to play forza3 so that we njoi the real DAMAGE SYSTEM?!! C'mon dood....

Well, no. You don't have to ditch GT5 at all. Just know that you are not playing the most realistic racing simulation, that's all. Even GT5's AI will probably be the same as GT4. Polyphony was always about number of cars, tracks and how the cars looked. Sure they've done a great job on the physics, but they've never gone the extra mile like Forza has. Full customizable cars with incredible paint jobs and a auction to sell the cars to gamers all over the world. Forza 3 will be in my hands on day one.



__________________________________________

'gaming till I'm gone'

ocnkng on 19 August 2009
yo_john117 said:

I really don't care one way or another, but I do get to laugh at Twingo!  I remember him saying countless times that if GT had damage, it would be true damage and not the fake bullshit damage that Forza has.  Well looks like he gets some crow :)

So its proven that GT5 has fake damage? I guess Waron's inane mumblings were more then enough evidence.

True for Xbot fanboys.



 

It is better to die on one's feet

then live on one's knees