It'll sell around 2.5 - 3 Million. But if they bundle it, then I think it can sell for around 4 + Mill

Yeah, I don't see this being a system seller.

He is as ugly as that Cole guy from Infamous. I would say both will sell about the same.

3 million max under all surcomstances. The last one did, what, some 2.5 million on the PS2.

Well, but the base don't like looks to mean much for sales. Look at MGS4, it sold the same that MGS3 sold in 100 million base at a 20 million base, I think base don't count much for this kind of game, people uses to buy a console for this games.

His "logic" fails. MGS4 outsold MGS3, God of War 3 could very well do the same.

MGS4 sold 4 million last year with a small userbase
And there was always piracy that was a huge issue with the ps2

Good observation, PS2 had 120 million base, but how much actually bought games? And remember a thing, sometimes the userbase doubles, but the software sales still the same.

Most people that would buy the game already own a PS3. There will be a bump but not a FF13 in Japan bump.

No. Super Mario Bros. 3 was hyped. Killzone was hyped. This doesn't compare.

But the PS2's fanbase wasn't made generally of hardcore players. The PS3 seems to be more "hardcore". I believe with the proper advertising, it could exceed four million lifetime.