15 Super Mario Brothers 3 (+)

14 Super Mario RPG (-)
14 Super Mario World
14 Mario Golf Advance Tour

13 Super Mario 64

12 New Super Mario Bros.
12 Paper Mario 2
12 Super Mario Sunshine

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Kart
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Tennis Power Tour

10 Super Smash Bros. Melee
10 Mario Kart Double Dash!!
10 Mario Golf
10 Super Paper Mario
10 Super Mario World 2
10 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
10 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
10 Mario Party Advance

9 Mario Kart Super Circuit
9 Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
9 Mario Party
9 Super Mario Strikers
9 Donkey Kong (GB)
9 Donkey Kong

8 Super Mario Bros. 2
8 Mario Tennis
8 Super Mario Land 2
8 Mario Strikers Charged
8 Super Mario Land
8 Mario Party 5
8 Super Smash Bros.

7 Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
7 Mario Party 2

6 Mario Party 3
6 Mario Bros.
6 Mario Kart 64
6 Mario Party 6

5 Mario Power Tennis

4 Mario Party 7

3 Mario Party 8 (-)

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

Vote 3 for 10/9/07

15 Super Mario Brothers 3
15 Super Mario RPG (+)

14 Super Mario World
14 Mario Golf Advance Tour

13 Super Mario 64

12 New Super Mario Bros.
12 Paper Mario 2
12 Super Mario Sunshine

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Kart
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Tennis Power Tour

10 Super Smash Bros. Melee
10 Mario Kart Double Dash!!
10 Mario Golf
10 Super Paper Mario
10 Super Mario World 2
10 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
10 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
10 Mario Party Advance

9 Mario Kart Super Circuit
9 Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
9 Mario Party
9 Super Mario Strikers
9 Donkey Kong (GB)
9 Donkey Kong

8 Mario Tennis
8 Super Mario Land 2
8 Mario Strikers Charged
8 Super Mario Land
8 Mario Party 5
8 Super Smash Bros.

7 Super Mario Bros. 2 (-)
7 Mario Party 2

6 Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga (-)
6 Mario Party 3
6 Mario Bros.
6 Mario Kart 64
6 Mario Party 6

5 Mario Power Tennis

4 Mario Party 7

3 Mario Party 8

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

Mario RPG not real Mario

16 Super Mario Brothers 3(+)

14 Super Mario RPG (-)
14 Super Mario World
14 Mario Golf Advance Tour

13 Super Mario 64

12 New Super Mario Bros.
12 Paper Mario 2
12 Super Mario Sunshine

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Kart
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Tennis Power Tour

10 Super Smash Bros. Melee
10 Mario Kart Double Dash!!
10 Mario Golf
10 Super Paper Mario
10 Super Mario World 2
10 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
10 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
10 Mario Party Advance

9 Mario Kart Super Circuit
9 Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
9 Mario Party
9 Super Mario Strikers
9 Donkey Kong (GB)
9 Donkey Kong

8 Mario Tennis
8 Super Mario Land 2
8 Mario Strikers Charged
8 Super Mario Land
8 Mario Party 5
8 Super Smash Bros.

7 Mario Party 2

6 Super Mario Bros. 2 (-)
6 Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga
6 Mario Party 3
6 Mario Bros.
6 Mario Kart 64
6 Mario Party 6

5 Mario Power Tennis

4 Mario Party 7

3 Mario Party 8

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

Vote 4 for 10/9/07

16 Super Mario Brothers 3

15 Super Mario RPG (+)

14 Super Mario World
14 Mario Golf Advance Tour

13 Super Mario 64

12 New Super Mario Bros.
12 Paper Mario 2
12 Super Mario Sunshine

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Kart
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Tennis Power Tour

10 Super Smash Bros. Melee
10 Mario Kart Double Dash!!
10 Mario Golf
10 Super Paper Mario
10 Super Mario World 2
10 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
10 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
10 Mario Party Advance

9 Mario Kart Super Circuit
9 Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
9 Mario Party
9 Super Mario Strikers
9 Donkey Kong (GB)
9 Donkey Kong

8 Mario Tennis
8 Super Mario Land 2
8 Mario Strikers Charged
8 Super Mario Land
8 Super Smash Bros.

7 Mario Party 2
7 Mario Party 5

6 Super Mario Bros. 2 (-)
6 Mario Party 3
6 Mario Bros.
6 Mario Kart 64
6 Mario Party 6

5 Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga (-)
5 Mario Power Tennis

3 Mario Party 7
3 Mario Party 8

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

Vote 5 for 10/9/07

16 Super Mario Brothers 3
16 Super Mario RPG (+)

14 Super Mario World
14 Mario Golf Advance Tour

13 Super Mario 64

12 New Super Mario Bros.
12 Paper Mario 2
12 Super Mario Sunshine

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Kart
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Tennis Power Tour

10 Super Smash Bros. Melee
10 Mario Kart Double Dash!!
10 Mario Golf
10 Super Paper Mario
10 Super Mario World 2
10 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
10 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
10 Mario Party Advance

9 Mario Kart Super Circuit
9 Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
9 Mario Party
9 Super Mario Strikers
9 Donkey Kong (GB)
9 Donkey Kong

8 Mario Tennis
8 Super Mario Land 2
8 Mario Strikers Charged
8 Super Mario Land
8 Super Smash Bros.

7 Mario Party 2
7 Mario Party 5

6 Mario Party 3
6 Mario Bros.
6 Mario Kart 64
6 Mario Party 6

5 Super Mario Bros. 2 (-)
5 Mario Power Tennis

4 Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga (-)

3 Mario Party 7
3 Mario Party 8

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

@Rol - What makes you want to save Super Mario Bros. 2 so much?

Vote 6 for 10/8/07

16 Super Mario Brothers 3
16 Super Mario RPG

14 Super Mario World
14 Mario Golf Advance Tour

13 Super Mario 64

12 New Super Mario Bros.
12 Paper Mario 2
12 Super Mario Sunshine

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Kart
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Tennis Power Tour
11 Super Smash Bros. Melee (+)

10 Mario Kart Double Dash!!
10 Mario Golf
10 Super Paper Mario
10 Super Mario World 2
10 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
10 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
10 Mario Party Advance

9 Mario Kart Super Circuit
9 Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
9 Mario Party
9 Super Mario Strikers
9 Donkey Kong (GB)
9 Donkey Kong

8 Mario Tennis
8 Super Mario Land 2
8 Mario Strikers Charged
8 Super Mario Land
8 Super Smash Bros.

6 Mario Party 2
6 Mario Party 5
6 Mario Party 3
6 Mario Bros.
6 Mario Kart 64
6 Mario Party 6

5 Super Mario Bros. 2 (-)
5 Mario Power Tennis

3 Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga (-)
3 Mario Party 7
3 Mario Party 8

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

RolStoppable said: Words Of Wisdom said: @Rol - What makes you want to save Super Mario Bros. 2 so much? What makes you want to kill Super Mario Bros. 2 so much? There are worse games than SMB2 on the list which should be eliminated before, that's the reason why I am adding points to this game. Once enough other games have been eliminated or if you stop deducting points from it, I focus on a different game. Besides, SMB2 was the second NES game I have played, the first one was SMB. I have good memories of this game. Let's just eliminate all the Mario Party games and some sports games before SMB2, okay?

My experience is almost diametrically opposite as far as that goes.  The first two games I played for the NES Super Mario Bros. 3 and Kung Fu.  Super Mario Bros. 3 (likely among my top 3 favorite Mario games ever) and the original would come later with SMB-2 coming last.  Just never had the appeal of the other two.

As for the Mario party games, I can agree to that.  If you don't (+) SMB-2 any further than 5/6, I won't (-) it any further. 

Truce? 

16 Super Mario Brothers 3
16 Super Mario RPG

14 Super Mario World
14 Mario Golf Advance Tour

13 Super Mario 64

12 New Super Mario Bros.
12 Paper Mario 2
12 Super Mario Sunshine

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Kart
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Tennis Power Tour
11 Super Smash Bros. Melee

10 Mario Kart Double Dash!!
10 Mario Golf
10 Super Paper Mario
10 Super Mario World 2
10 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
10 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
10 Mario Party Advance

9 Mario Kart Super Circuit
9 Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
9 Mario Party
9 Super Mario Strikers

8 Donkey Kong (-)
8 Mario Tennis
8 Donkey Kong (GB) (-)
8 Super Mario Land 2
8 Mario Strikers Charged
8 Super Mario Land
8 Super Smash Bros.

6 Mario Party 2
6 Mario Party 5
6 Mario Party 3
6 Mario Bros.
6 Mario Kart 64
6 Mario Party 6

5 Super Mario Bros. 2
5 Mario Power Tennis

4 Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga (+)

3 Mario Party 7
3 Mario Party 8

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

17 Super Mario Brothers 3(+)

16 Super Mario RPG

14 Super Mario World
14 Mario Golf Advance Tour

13 Super Mario 64

12 New Super Mario Bros.
12 Paper Mario 2

11 Paper Mario
11 Mario Kart DS
11 Super Mario Kart
11 Super Mario Bros.
11 Mario Tennis Power Tour
11 Super Smash Bros. Melee
11 Super Mario Sunshine (-)

10 Mario Kart Double Dash!!
10 Mario Golf
10 Super Paper Mario
10 Super Mario World 2
10 Super Mario Bros. The Lost Levels
10 Mario Golf Toadstool Tour
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong
10 Mario vs. Donkey Kong 2
10 Mario Party Advance

9 Mario Kart Super Circuit
9 Mario & Luigi Partners in Time
9 Mario Party
9 Super Mario Strikers

8 Donkey Kong (-)
8 Mario Tennis
8 Donkey Kong (GB) (-)
8 Super Mario Land 2
8 Mario Strikers Charged
8 Super Mario Land
8 Super Smash Bros.

6 Mario Party 2
6 Mario Party 5
6 Mario Party 3
6 Mario Bros.
6 Mario Kart 64
6 Mario Party 6

5 Super Mario Bros. 2
5 Mario Power Tennis

4 Mario & Luigi Superstar Saga (+)

3 Mario Party 7
3 Mario Party 8

Eliminated:

1. Mario Hoops 3-on-3
2. DDR Mario Mix
3. Mario Superstar Baseball
4. Mario Party 4
5. SSX On Tour

Rules: Add 1 point (+) to a game, deduct 1 point (-) from 2 different games.
You can vote once per hour, so theoretically up to 24 times a day.
Copy and paste this list with your changes and these rules in each post.

Whoa whoa, there was a Mario Party Advance?

Man, I've always wanted a Mario Party on handheld, I thought the upcoming DS version in Japan would be the first. But Advance sucked apparently?