By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - Interesting article: Americans favor science, but less than before

Source

Americans favor science, but less than before

WASHINGTON (AP) — The share of Americans who see science as the nation's greatest achievement is down sharply, even as the public continues to hold scientists in high regard.

A new Pew Research Center poll indicates that 27 percent of Americans say the nation's greatest achievements are in science, medicine and technology, more than any category other than don't know.

But that's down from 47 percent in a similar study a decade ago, the center reported Thursday.

The decline comes even as technology reaches out to connect people worldwide via the Internet.

But the era of "Big Science," like the moon landings, has receded into history, while one-time wonders such as organ transplants seem increasingly routine and the battle against cancer drags on.

Probably reflecting last fall's historic election of Barack Obama as president, the poll found that people rating equal rights as the nation's top achievement jumped to 17 percent, compared with just 5 percent 10 years earlier.

Most Americans — 64 percent — see this country's science as "above average," but with advances by other countries getting increasing attention, just 17 percent say it's the best in the world. Indeed, the European Union currently published more scientific papers than the United States.

There is the danger, over time, that the United States could lose its pre-eminence in science and efforts to interest more young people in research are under way, said Alan I. Leshner, head of the American Association for the Advancement of Science.

Overall, the new study found that science remains well thought of by Americans, with 84 percent of respondents saying it has a mostly positive effect on society. Only 6 percent rated science as largely negative for society.

There was no exact earlier comparison for those numbers, but Scott Keeter, director of the survey, said other studies over the years have shown consistently positive views of science and medicine.

"The U.S. public recognizes research and development, perhaps especially to drive medical advances, as an investment in the future. Yet, researchers and the public too often are separated by a communications gap," said Leshner. He said his group is conducting seminars teaching scientists how to better communicate with the public.

Even when they disagreed with some findings, people showed an overall positive outlook for science.

For example, 63 percent of respondents who believe in creationism and 64 percent of those contending there is no evidence of global warming still said science does much to contribute to the well-being of society.

The new report is based on a series of three polls. The first was a telephone survey of 2,001 members of the general public April 28-May 12, asking their opinions of science. The second, testing the public's scientific knowledge, was a sample of 1,005 adults June 18-21. For comparison, the Pew researchers also conducted an online random sample of 2,533 members of the AAAS from May 1 to June 14. AAAS is an international organization of scientists and those interested in science.

Among the findings:

_ About 91 percent of the general public knew that aspirin is recommended to prevent heart attacks, 82 percent knew that global positioning systems rely on satellites and 65 percent correctly linked carbon dioxide gas to rising temperatures.

_On the other hand, just 54 percent understood that antibiotics do not kill viruses and fewer than half — 46 percent — knew that electrons are smaller than atoms.

_Men have a more favorable outlook about science than women, 86 percent saying it has a mostly positive effect, compared with 81 percent.

_Science got an 87 percent favorable rating from whites, compared with 76 percent among blacks and 75 percent for Hispanics.

_ The public and scientists did not always see eye-to-eye. For example 87 percent of scientists believed that humans and other living things evolved naturally, compared with 32 percent of the general public (WTF at the disparity on that one!). And while 84 percent of scientists say the Earth is getting warmer because of human activities, just 49 percent of the public agreed.

_A majority of the public — 58 percent — favor federal funding for embryonic stem cell research, but that is well short of the 93 percent of scientists who feel that way.

_ And 69 percent of Americans say all parents should be required to vaccinate their children, compared with 82 percent of scientists.

 



Around the Network

_Science got an 87 percent favorable rating from whites, compared with 76 percent among blacks and 75 percent for Hispanics.

I dont understand why there is such a gap there.

Interesting find

highwaystar101
*Online*



I thought so too. Some of those figures were very surprising. The disparity between some of them (Scientist to public opinion) was immense.



Well i think that clear, your average scientist has a higher IQ to your average citizen.

There would most likely be the same disparity in the results had it shown the top 5% of the country (inteligence wise) vs the bottom 5%



FootballFan said:
Well i think that clear, your average scientist has a higher IQ to your average citizen.

There would most likely be the same disparity in the results had it shown the top 5% of the country (inteligence wise) vs the bottom 5%

Agreed, I could see a large disparity in that situation too. I wonder if anyone has done that? I'll check



Around the Network
highwaystar101 said:

Source

_ The public and scientists did not always see eye-to-eye. For example 87 percent of scientists believed that humans and other living things evolved naturally, compared with 32 percent of the general public (WTF at the disparity on that one!). And while 84 percent of scientists say the Earth is getting warmer because of human activities, just 49 percent of the public agreed.

Shows that sometimes scientists are actually less knowledgable about the reality than the public is.



Slimebeast said:
highwaystar101 said:

Source

_ The public and scientists did not always see eye-to-eye. For example 87 percent of scientists believed that humans and other living things evolved naturally, compared with 32 percent of the general public (WTF at the disparity on that one!). And while 84 percent of scientists say the Earth is getting warmer because of human activities, just 49 percent of the public agreed.

Shows that sometimes scientists are actually less knowledgable about the reality than the public is.


Scientists have to exaggerate in certain situations. Exaggeration creates fear. This leads to rich people donating to scientific research.

And i agree with you on this one, human activity does have a certain part to play. Just nothing like on the scale that scientists talk about.



Slimebeast said:
highwaystar101 said:

Source

_ The public and scientists did not always see eye-to-eye. For example 87 percent of scientists believed that humans and other living things evolved naturally, compared with 32 percent of the general public (WTF at the disparity on that one!). And while 84 percent of scientists say the Earth is getting warmer because of human activities, just 49 percent of the public agreed.

 

 

Shows that sometimes scientists are actually less knowledgable about the reality than the public is.

Pardon me?

I see, and what primary research have you done slimebeast, as a member of the general public, with regards to climate change?

And how much research have the scientists done for climate change? A lot and they all have pretty much the same basic conclusion. Seriously, my Gfs dad did his PhD studying climate change and researched it proffesionally for years, I will take him as an average climatologist. He agrees, he says it's overblown by the media, but it is happening and a fair part of it is man made.



Highwaystar. I believe there is a cycle controlling temperatures. We are just at the tip of a new one. The 1990s was the hottest decade since 1860s, and im pretty sure it wasnt global warming then. Ill just try to find some infomation about this cycle.



highwaystar101 said:
Slimebeast said:
highwaystar101 said:

Source

_ The public and scientists did not always see eye-to-eye. For example 87 percent of scientists believed that humans and other living things evolved naturally, compared with 32 percent of the general public (WTF at the disparity on that one!). And while 84 percent of scientists say the Earth is getting warmer because of human activities, just 49 percent of the public agreed.

 

 

Shows that sometimes scientists are actually less knowledgable about the reality than the public is.

Pardon me?

I see, and what primary research have you done slimebeast, as a member of the general public, with regards to climate change?

And how much research have the scientists done for climate change? A lot and they all have pretty much the same basic conclusion. Seriously, my Gfs dad did his PhD studying climate change and researched it proffesionally for years, I will take him as an average climatologist. He agrees, he says it's overblown by the media, but it is happening and a fair part of it is man made.


The warming has stopped since 7 years. Thus they renamed it 'climate change' LOL.

And if u want sources, read HappySquirrel's amd Sqrl's posts for a start.