I think this reasonable fellow has already tried to start a war! His subtle trolling will not work on me! I know what kind of person he is, and that person tried to remind the Xbox fanboys that Natal was passed over by the IGN PS3 team in a strictly Sony v Sony contest.

We're going to be reasonable in this war!!!!

No.  Clearly.  For some reason I'm having trouble looking at IGN right now - I keep getting re-directed to UK site.  I thought only the Sony element had been posted.

Now it all makes sense!

Guess as far as the critics are concerned Uchanrted 2 is looking to be PS3's critical darling this year.

Now can anyone tell me how to look at IGN.COM and not have it decide because I'm in UK I have to look at UK site?  Pretty please...

EDIT : Subtle Trolling!  Squil... you are a comedian!  I'm just not paying attention this morning (and arguing with my browser rather than reading carefully).

DOUBLE EDIT: I now realize it was the openning line of 'reveal their PS3 and 360 winners' which threw me.  I skimmed through, more interested in why I couldn't get to ign.com, and replied without looking overly closely at the list.  The moral:  read closely before you post.

Final Fantasy finally won an RPG award. Its about damn time (LOL).

^ I wanna know too! But I must agree Uncharted 2 does seem like the critical darling this year which is disapointing because I seriously think that of all the games to help Sony MAG could be the one if they do it right mr Reasonable.

Mag looks awesome. I'm really looking forward too it. It seemed to run smooth and well.. has a cool art direction too. I don't get why none of the big media give it credit.. Oh well. I hope it'll do well when it comes out :p

The lack of Ratchet winning the platforming category is slightly disturbing, though of course Uncharted 2 might just have won that won as well

Was Modern Warfare 2 not shown there? Because I doubt U2AT will have better MP than MW2, but great to see Naughty Dog doing so well, I think Uncharted 2 has what it takes to take game of the year this year, and I would be very surprised if it was not game of E3

Really? To me, it looks so bland and uninteresting. It's difficult to fairly assess it when there are so many other promising shooter-type games coming out around the same time.

OT: I thought the awards were spot on. I thought Sony had the best showing in terms of games (had to have been when they had to show so many, seemingly, great games only through a montage), but had the worst conference. The two guys presenting the motion controllers were so obviously incompetent at presentation.

Haha, U2 FTW!

MAG was a disappointment from what I saw looks I will be getting MW2

@ the thunder, I think it was a poor move making an online only FPS, which was not SOCOM, as there is so much competition and it will be very hard to convince people to get MAG as well as or instead of Modern Warfare 2