twesterm said:
ssj12 said:
twesterm said:
Engelos said:
twesterm said:
I'm actually still confused on when it tells you to "draw" your card. It didn't show up anywhere in that video other than just telling the player to draw (or search being the better term). -edit-
The more I think about it, yeah, I pretty much agree with Fuzz on this. 1) You have to buy an extra accessory.
2) You have to buy the cards.
3) Registering every card in your deck one by one will suck.
4) Modifying your deck is going to be just as annoying (because you will modify the deck after most games).
5) There's no point to the cards. None at all. Furthermore, you have to line up the cards just right to get them read.
6) You can still print your own cards.
7) There's no depth to the game. This might be good for people that don't do CCG's (you know, the people that this game isn't marketed towards) but anyone who has even played Pokemon will see an extremely shallow game.
8) In any tic tac toe type of game, the player who goes first has an extreme advantage.
9) Those animations for drawing, playing a card, summoning, getting mana, casting a spell, attacking, defending, and everything else better be skippable (which they won't because it's two player across distance). They will be cool for the first few games but they will get old very quickly. |
1 - there like 10 wii accesories, PS2 eye games sold well enough.
2 - No shiet, you have to buy cards for a dunn dunn dun a card game.
3 - i guess playing agianst cheeters is more fun.
4 - your opinion, based on nothing.
5 - lIts a card game, why cant you understand that?
6 - WTF
7 - those that played have said he opposite but you would know better, right.
8 - lol
9 - yahh counting the stats your self would be much more fun. |
I was going to dignify this with a response but you're really not worth it. |
no, Engelos is right. Sorry but your way off with your opinions. Its a card game, you have to spend money on cards, I have over 2 grand worth of Yu-Gi-Oh cards and I know about 80 people at my old high school that still buy tons of cards and have more then me. They are all looking forward to Eye of Judgment because its similar to the battling in the anime. To have real holographic tech like in the anime we would need several million dollars to buy a 2D holo-projector. Thats not cheap. The way the cards are made it would be really hard to print your own cards as they all have magnetic strips in them for the PSEye to read. Yes for the face to face none-PSEye gameplay you can cheat and have fake cards but for battling someone in Japan from America you need the PSEye and fake cards wont work. As for gameplay have you even seen it being played? There is some interesting battling in it because theres spell cards and battling so capturing 5 squares wont be as easy as 5th turn you win. Please check your facts before you post, you make yourself look stupid. Also you might want to look up what a CCG and TCG is because you dont seem to know what those are since Pokemon is a TCG and your implying that its a CCG. |
You're right, I didn't know what TCG meant so I looked it up. Do you know what one is? From what I see it's just another name for a CCG. It seems like bickering that something is a TCG or CCG is even less pointless than trying to figure out if Metroid is a FPS or FPA. Yes, Metroid is n adventure game but it will always be lumped in FPS games. As for my comment to Engelos, when someone shows absolutely no respect and tries to argue by just using the OMG that's stupid method then they aren't worth my time. You actually bothered to say something so I'll actually bother replying. So yeah, you're right; I know nothing at all about card games. I only worked in a gaming shop (mentioned here), played M:t, Pokemon, and Dragonball Z pretty hardcore for a while as well as played Magination, Legend of the Five Rings, Star Wars, UFS, Yu-Gi-Oh, UFS, Inuyasha, and even a few more that I just can't remember the names of. So yes, I know nothing about card games. Now that we're through assuming, lets talk about Eye of Judgment. I know you have to spend money on it and I know it's a card game. My gripes are that it's a card game where the cards absolutely do not matter and even though a lot of people are excited about it, it's going to be too shallow for heavy card gamers and not worth the time to buy cards because just about everyone is going to cheat anyways (printing their own cards). All it takes is a decent printer and a picture of the card and *gasp* you have a proxy. I know people that made many proxy M:tG cards more than 10 years ago on crap printers that fooled many people (some used them for bad, others just wanted good looking proxy cards) and it would be even easier to do today. Now you did mention magnetic strips on the cards, I hadn't heard about that. Until I see proof (and there very well could be-- not afraid to admit I'm wrong) I'm going to assume it's some kind of bar code that the eye can just see and scan. As for the animations, they will be cool for the first 10 minutes but they will get old quickly. No matter how much you love anime or mechs, they will get old because they are long and you have to sit through them. Little repeating cut scenes like that are usually trouble in a two player game because they are hard to skip. If you want some perfect examples of small cut repeating cut scenes you can't skip just play NCAA 2007 (I think it's that year). After most plays you have to watch the players run to the huddle and that can't be skipped. Every time you want to kick the ball you have to watch the players set up and that can't be skipped. There are more, but I can't remember where they are and you get the point. You can't have just one player want to skip them, both want to. It's easy to make a little notification in the corner saying (player 1 wants to skip!) but it's still a messy way to do things. I'll be interested to see if they do in fact do something to skip these. Also, I get that 5th turn doesn't equal win and there will be interesting battles, but in a game that's capture the most squares, the first player does get the huge advantage. In a game like M:tG you get a card advantage for going second which is great but I'm not so sure that it will be worth so much in this game. This game really does just look like a Pokemon at its simplest level type of play. Don't get me wrong about Pokemon, it's great that have such a simple system that a 6 year old can grasp while still doing some cool strategies (I use to have an energyless deck that owned all) but until I see some proof of deeper gameplay, this game just looks pretty stupid simple. So far it looks so stupid simple that some people will play it for the novelty, but most hard core CCG (or TCG whatever you want to call it) will pass it off as too simple and go back to their traditional card games. |
