who do you think has the best motion controller after seeing all thr showings??

i think sony's is the best but its gonna suck to have to go out and buy a brand new controller, but its pretty much 2 wii motion plus's in two hands

MS seems pretty limited, and more like a chore, like holding on to a invisible steering wheel, and idk how there gonna do fps with no buttons

Nintendo has wiimotion plus and its only 10 or 20 bucks more, buts seems limited compared to Sony's hopefully nintendo will have something to counter them in the future

but all in all even thogh nintendo already has the motion controller out and they own that market i see its going to get very competetive in the future.

Nintendo:good since its the only one on the market, seems cheapest, but will be surpassed

Sony:seems the best, but will have to get players to buy another controller

MS:um.....idk make elephants LOLZ, it really doesnt seem like it will make good games especially with no controller or buttons

What is ur opinion??????

The Sony one for me kid. It was just seriously accurate and because it works along side the PSeye You can star in the game at the same time or even get your head motion tracked buy the PSeye whilst you doing the motion controller aswell.

The writing on the wall was good to be honest. They should of gotten someone more talented to talk about it though. The man on stage just looked nervous

None, although i sort of like sonys buts its fucking hard to control and im to lazy to use it unless its for really great games like Flower or Folklore.

Still when used right, Wii's can be great to.

And we don't know much about MS's one yet.

Wii by default right now, until i play the other ones

yea i think once the sony gets in the markets its gonna be a lot better buts it too late to make an impact because wiimotion is already out and game are already in development

Wiimote, without WM+. 1:1 is bad for gaming, limiting the interface to do-as-I-do rather than the more fun and entertaining do-what-I-mean. Gesture-based controls, as the Wiimote currently provides, are far superior for gaming interfaces, because they don't tie the onscreen character to the player's capabilities. No gamer will ever be as good with a sword as, say, Link or Kratos need to be, so you have two options when making a 1:1 game: dumb it down severely or everybody dies. Either way, it's just not fun. Unfortunately, the people who are clamoring for 1:1 have never actually used it, but it looks like they'll get their chance, and then they'll see the inherent flaws in what they've been begging for.

The only way to keep developers from misbehaving and going for buzzword-compliance over quality is to block them out of it. The Wii, with quality and innovation not seen on a home console in three generations, showed this as concerns graphics. Now we're going to see this as a matter of gestures versus 1:1, but it threatens to take gaming in the wrong direction, away from the balance between abstraction and immersion that expressive gesture-based control provides. We'd finally been getting out of the rut of the past two gens, and this could to push us right back into it.

Let me put it this way.

Imagine you had three friends.
Friend A had a beat up Ford Truck, that worked pretty well most of the time.
Friend B didn't have a car right now, but when he got the money, in couple years, he's gonna buy a nice Honda with all the amenities.
Friend C doesn't have a car either, and he's planning on buying a Ferarri. that can fly. In space.

Of your three friends, which has the best car? Friend A, the one who actually has a car.

Sony and Microsoft are maybe getting Motion Control in the 2-3 year time frame. Maybe. Nintendo has it now, and will have Wii Motion Plus in a week.

but. microsofts controller isn't a controller.

on topic i have not seen enough of any of them to make a decision

Sony's by a mile. Followed closely by Wii Motion +.

Natal looks and sounds good but holding something help me feel more realism so I'm gonna have to say sony. Nintendos wii motion plus n Sony 1:1 control is what I realy want. but natal is what Im most excited about, next gen with 1:1 control 3-d n body motion tracking how noes what else we will have... Virtual reality!!!