I would give it a 9/10. I would of liked to see some pikmin 3 and fire emblem. I think the vitality bar has alot of potential. If it can interpret how your feeling the game could change radically for nintendo.

I'm really excited about golden sun ds, and New Metroid.

8/10

Won points for:
KH DS
Golden Sun
NSMB Wii (though I don't think it'll work out very well)
SMG2 (didn't gain as many points for me due to it being another galaxy game, but Yoshi addition is epic)
Mario and Luigi RPG
Metroid: Other M

Lost points for:
Talk of Wii motion plus - We get it - You spent a lot of last E3 talking about it - We get it
Casual games (even cammie labelled them as such) - It's a video games conference attended by gaming media, we don't care about FASHIONISTA GAMES.
No new IP's from Nintendo (EDIT: Should say no new franchises)

EDIT: Also, I said this after MS conference (I thanked them for it), NO NEED TO DISCUSS SALES NUMBERS. We know you're winning and we know that the DSi was a run away success. Wasted precious time on it.

So 8/10. I gave MS a 8.5-9/10. The only difference between them for me is that MS tech presentation (Natal) was much more impressive than Nintendo's (sensor is okay, but WM+ was entirely un-necessary and didn't need to take up 10minutes). Both showed great games, but I'm highly sceptical about Metroid:Other M, the footage shown was so varied (3rd and 1st person views) that I'm not sure what to make of it. I'll bank on Nintendo to do well with it though.

So much win@this and your sig.

cleaner - There are tons of Nintendo fans on VGC. The distribution of fans seems to go 50/35/15 for Sony/Nintendo/MS.

7

spent the first half hour essentially summing up last e3. it only got interesting last 15 minutes(whenever they showed Galaxy2). im still hesitant about Galaxy and metroid because i had some issues with galaxy and i thought the last metroid was boring and complete garbage. that someone else has been working on metroid is the only reason i am even partially interested.

6 it was a 4 until MG2 it went up to 5 and then metroid another point... 6 is way better than 3 last year

10!

And also 10 times better than last year.Omg, i'm so happy with new games Nintendo and 3rd parties bring to us! XD

Awesome! :D

10.

Metroid, NSMB Wii, Galaxy 2, Mario and Luigi 3, Mario vs Donkey Kong 3, Golden Sun 3. Couldn't have asked for or expected more.

7
owuld have been 10 if zelda, s&p2, and pikmin 3 were there

Jesus Christ man...

NSMB Wii

Mario Galaxy 2

New Metroid

Those are only NIntendo's games. How could you give it a 5 from those just games...you must not be a fan of NIntendo at ALL. And if you are, you must only like Zelda or any franchise besides Mario and Metroid. Seriously, that Metroid announcement gives it 5 points alone. You're one crazy poster :p