8/10
Won points for:
KH DS
Golden Sun
NSMB Wii (though I don't think it'll work out very well)
SMG2 (didn't gain as many points for me due to it being another galaxy game, but Yoshi addition is epic)
Mario and Luigi RPG
Metroid: Other M
Lost points for:
Talk of Wii motion plus - We get it - You spent a lot of last E3 talking about it - We get it
Casual games (even cammie labelled them as such) - It's a video games conference attended by gaming media, we don't care about FASHIONISTA GAMES.
No new IP's from Nintendo (EDIT: Should say no new franchises)
EDIT: Also, I said this after MS conference (I thanked them for it), NO NEED TO DISCUSS SALES NUMBERS. We know you're winning and we know that the DSi was a run away success. Wasted precious time on it.
So 8/10. I gave MS a 8.5-9/10. The only difference between them for me is that MS tech presentation (Natal) was much more impressive than Nintendo's (sensor is okay, but WM+ was entirely un-necessary and didn't need to take up 10minutes). Both showed great games, but I'm highly sceptical about Metroid:Other M, the footage shown was so varied (3rd and 1st person views) that I'm not sure what to make of it. I'll bank on Nintendo to do well with it though.
