Well, we've had some classics in prior years. Lair and it's ridiculous motion controls, Haze and it's abundance of suck. Yet, we're looking forward now to the rest of 2009, and with so many hyped up releases, it will be hard to pin down which will fail most epically.
My money is on Infamous, though I could easily see one or two other titles blowing us away with their inadequacies.
So, what is your pick for PS3 flop of '09?
Stop getting so excited about a Kid Icarus remake... the original NES Icarus sucked.