I doubt LBP would do well, the community levels are what makes that game great and dont think the Wii would do that well. But that my opinion.

I would say Ratchet is a definite possibilty, same with Viva Pinata, and Banjo. I would also say alot of the JRPGs on either console would do well on the Wii.

You do have a point with galaxy being higher, but why on earth would carnival games sell like they do and madworld, fragile, okami, house of the dead, etc sell so pitifully?  That is because core gamers on the wii are not the majority, hence any core game (fallout, resident evil) will have roughly the same success on the wii as it has on HD twins is all I am saying.  Maybe less looking at WAW.

I guess you did not read what I was saying because of your bias towards the HD twins.  AGAIN I will attempt to open your mind, Resident evil 4 did very well on the wii (taking nothing from it), but RE5 was no slouch  on the Twins because it got it's sales within a month versus a couple of years.  Resident evil games have nice legs as well and should see both copies trending toward 3 to 4 million ltd (why? I have no idea, I did not like this game, but it has sold).  So I hope I can empart my opinion without being  attacked as a fanboy by you again in this same thread.  I am merely adding to the thread in away to help enlighten others that may find my post informative.  ciao.

A big fat hell no to all those games mentioned. Games like Banjo Kazooie 3 and Viva Pinata would have sold really well on Wii.

It's pretty pointless to debate on this, since we would never know how any of those PS360 game would've turned out on the inferior hardware. Some of those games are simply not possible on the Wii as they are, and it would mean a total different game, since graphics and physics have plenty to do with gameplay mechanics and the overall experience.

The wii is getting dead space so we will know about at least one of these predictions very soon. Yeah as far as shaders, physics, texture quality, and animation we know that the wii version would have been worlds behind the HD twins....but as far as controls are concerned the wii may just make it more fun (with it's waggle controls).
So again it is really a toss up.

Well Dead Space Wii is an on-rails game..Also by your reasoning the PS2 was in a similar position as well, since games like Spongebob Squarepants sold more than God of War.