By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - 12 Year Old Weighs in On Abortion!?

For the sake of the discussion I'm going to split this into two parts, first the substance of her speech and second her age.  Try to seperate the two issues in your replies for clarity (especially since someone's age really shouldn't effect the validity of their points).  As this can be a contentious issue I'd ask folks to make an extra effort to remain civil and respectful to the views of others.

My take on the video:  Well made points especially the point about responsibility not overriding someone else's rights, but the underlying point of the debate is still "When is it another person?" and there is simply no clear cut answer.  My take is that if we aren't sure we should err on the side of caution, but I personally draw the line at the start of brain waves because it is an objective line in the sand and the mind is "a", if not "the" only, major factor in the conscious identity of a human being. If it has a functioning human brain, even in early development, I have a hard time seeing how it could be anything but human.

My take on the age issue: Twelve is a bit young in general for this topic, but if she is as bright as she appears to be and she wrote it herself I've got no issue with it at 12. On the other hand if someone wrote it and had her read it I do have a real problem with it.  Kids shouldn't be exploited for adults to express their opinions through an innocent face, but kids who legitimately "get" the issues shouldn't be precluded from the discussion either, particularly when they're capable of actually adding a thoughtful and substantive position to the discussion....unlike many of the supposed adults on both sides of the issue.

Without proof one way or another on whether or not it is really her thoughts and choices behind this I'll leave the question open, but I'm certainly suspicious of it and I'd hope I'm not alone on that.

 



To Each Man, Responsibility
Around the Network

So, shes gonna have an abortion yeah?



I hope my 360 doesn't RRoD
         "Suck my balls!" - Tag courtesy of Fkusmot

Didn't change my opinion at all, but I'm too tired to get into a big debate lol.

I don't think that she wrote it personaly, she may believe the basics of what she is saying but I don't think it would have been her idea to do the speech and publish it online.



So because the latin word fetus means a young person then they are living and conscience... I doubt it.

... also she is twelve and has some very dubious facts.



I can pay for her abortion.



Around the Network
Sqrl said:

 

....unlike many of the supposed adults on both sides of the issue.

 

I think a couple of you have done a wonderful job of proving this point =P

 



To Each Man, Responsibility

Wow, what a bright girl.
I hope she got an "A" for the report.

I agree with everything she said, except abortion being illegal. I think we can do other things to support pro-life position.



She did very good.

It's sad that some of you are insulting her.



"We'll toss the dice however they fall,
And snuggle the girls be they short or tall,
Then follow young Mat whenever he calls,
To dance with Jak o' the Shadows."

Check out MyAnimeList and my Game Collection. Owner of the 5 millionth post.

im supposed to be impressed that the education system has produced another pro-lifer?



"Kill" an unborn child hardly capable of thought, or allow them to be born into a harsh world where their own parents probably don't even want them.

She really needs to stop making it sound like were talking about children dying of starvation er somethin.



http://soundcloud.com/cathode

PSN: Parasitic_Link