That is hard....if the game has sucky controls I probably will stop playing it;..even when it is very addictive.

Anyway a game just must be fun :).

Tits.

Great gameplay, nice story, good controls are what really makes a game worthy. All of that = fun.

Sadly, this is how you get to be AAA, without this you're stuck in 80s territory. If you have some of this, then high 80s. But the gaming media creates AAA titles, not programmers and artists.

Great gameplay, good controls and bringing something new or exciting to the table. Graphics? Nah ...

I think most people on this site will agree.

1.The game has to be a PS3 exclusive
2.The game has "Only possible on PS3"
3.The game has hype and will sell millions first day
4.The game is a system mover
5.The game has best graphics.