Bioshock
I remember the Game Informer cover article on BS, I was sold on it then, and all of these great reviews have solidified that.
As for the rest, Halo is way over-rated. XBOX was my favorite system last gen, and I WAS NOT part of the Halo army. Just because some one finally figured out how to make an FPS NOT SUCK on a console, does not mean that its gold. Besides, the original Metroid Prime was a better story mode game, and you can go all the way back to Goldeneye for a better multiplayer experience.
PGR4 - racing game . . . no thank you, I'll keep my $60 please.
Blue Dragon - looks interesting, has gotten beat up on reviews. Not sure I could stomach another inventice, but ultimately mediocre JRPG. Besides, the art style is TOO Dragonball Z for my tastes.
Mass Effect was a very close second. I mean CLOSE. Bioware has done some excellent work, and I loved the KOTOR series. But, because I invested some 150+ hours into those, something new like Bioshock would have to win out, if I could only get one.












