http://www.gamepro.com/article/news/208499/the-top-10-rpgs-of-2008/

Yay Persona. 2x

Valkyria.... Chronicles.... not.... high..... enough....

I liked the list that was posted a while back better, mostly because it was a bunch of people coming to a consensus and therefore was a useful list to look at, while this is just using metacritic and anyone could do that easily enough themselves. Wish I could remember who made that other list though.

edit: also according to his VC summary he doesn't seem to realize that Fallout 3 is on the PS3, unless he thinks that VC is better than Fallout 3 which goes against the order of the list he made.

For me it would be:

-Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 4
-Valkyria Chronicles
-Fallout 3
-Tales of Vesperia
-Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3
-Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII
-Lost Odyssey
-The World Ends with You
-Disgaea 3
-Fable II

What is Mass Effect, The Witcher and Chrono Trigger doing on the list, they were released on the US before 2008... PC version, enhancement and DS remake don't count...