The only game I returned was the new tomb raider, and I only did that so I could buy a better game.

- MGS4 (terrible story, too easy, lame answers and too many cutscenes, little gameplay)

- Final Fantasy X-2 (Too girly)

- Yoshi's Story (I thought this was going to be like Yoshi's Island, but I was wrong. Too easy, didn't like that you had to eat 30 fruits to beat the level, and I hated the singing after beating a level.)

- PSP (Weak library/game drought)

Prince of Persia: Sands of Time (painfully brief)
Tony Hawk's Underground (my first and last skating game)
Resident Evil 4: PS2 version (having half the ammo of the GC version makes it half as fun)
Burnout 3 (boring and repetative)
Tekken 4 (juggle like a clown)
Tekken 5 (less juggling but too much is lifted from VF4E)
Jak II (increasing the difficulty of many games simply make their flaws more apparent)
Final Fantasy VIII - X (the decline of one of my favorite franchises)
Sonic Advance (an average sonic game with some terrible level design)
Unreal II (just plain mediocre)
Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker (boring sailing, lousy stealth sequence, art direction that made my eyes physically ache and throb!)
Super Mario: Sunshine (terrible camera system, boring music, frustrating)

I could go on and on, I've sold over a hundred games over the years and I keep the games that I like.

Dragon Blade - Played it, and gave up.

Star Wars Force Unleashed - Such a terrible game.

Geist - Why Nintendo... why?

Final Fantasy X-2 - The beginning of the end for Final Fantasy

Viewtiful Joe 1-2 & R.H. Rumble - These games have no conventional replay value what-so-ever, are so linear and difficult that the unique and enjoyable battle system simply can't salvage them.

usually I never get rid of my games no matter how crappy. I have come very close to losing this one though .... "unlimited saga" (anyone want it for free?)

I have a ton of SNES games my parents bought me that I only played once/or never even played.

Mass Effect(great story can't salvage a lame combat system and bad mako controls)

I don't care what reaction I get from saying this

Metal Gear Solid 4.

I wish I hadn't bought it. I have no idea whats going on in the story, it makes no sense. and the action sequences aren't as intense as in FPS games.

I don't get rid of games but I do regret buying the following (this gen):

DoA4
DMC4
MGS4
GTA4
Soul Calibur 4
Fantastic 4 rise of silver surfer (gift certificate purchase so technically free)

(Street fighter 4 is easily one of my most anticipated titles this generation.... but I'm not liking the above trend so far.)

Sonic (wii)
Rampage (wii)
Marvel ultimate alliance (wii)

Well I haven't traded in any current gen games. I somehow manage to find enjoyment out of even critically bashed titles like Sonic Next-gen and Soul Calibur Legends (Though only for the first few hours). There are some I can name off the top of my head though:

Epidemic- Generic FPS on PS1 nobody heard of and I never got into myself.
Army Men: Sarge's Heroes- Another PS1 title that was just WAY too easy and short.
A scratched up God of War II- It was scratched up to the point of where the game wouldn't save after a certain point, so I traded in for a new copy.