Where's cooking mama?!

GTA3 was a sandbox game

MGS3 was probably a stealth game (never played it)

GTA4 and MGS4 were shooters

sorry champ

GTA4 will win, great game but not like san andreas was.

The list is great anyway, for me LBP is the GOTY with Fallout3 close second

Not including Wii Fit in that list is massive fail.

You can beat MGS4 without firing a bullet. Well, no you can't. But you can beat MGS4 without killing a single person.

GTA's focus is not on shooting, it is on taking your friends out for dates and then killing them and whatnot.

So, GTA is a sandbox, MGS is a stealth game.

 I'm not surprised. Regardless of whether the games deserve it, it is obvious that they would chose the HD games.

I've never seen one of these shows, but I'm guessing that they show small clips of them, right? Well, if you have 4 HD games, with good CGI and some really nice in game parts, and then Mario Kart Wii, which looks worse than some of the games that were nominated 4 years ago, it is just going to seem like it isn't serious at all.

HD games are far, far better for showing off than Wii games, and in a way showing off is what these shows are all about.

LBP GOTY for me with Fallout 3 an acceptable alternative.

I've actually played this game you know, so you're going to have to do better than that.

Yes, you can go through the game using the tranq gun, but that's still a shooter, not stealth

 Don't you get a tranquilizer gun relatively early, that fires arrows (tranquilizer bullets seem kinda odd), which means that you can avoic firing bullets?

I haven't played the game, but just thought about that.

Fallout 3 FTW. Well Brawl is game of the year but as no one seems interested in nominating any Wii game that isn't Galaxy for any GOTY award then the GOTY on HD consoles should win and that is Fallout 3.