Preliminary Results
(in order of elimination)

1 - Yu-Gi-Oh!
2 - Nickelodeon
3 - WWE SmackDown
4 - Harry Potter
5 - Madden NFL
6 - Grand Theft Auto
7 - Simple
8 - Dragonball Z
9 - FIFA
10 - Winning Eleven (PES)
11 - Marvel
12 - Tony Hawk
13 - Alone in the Dark
14 - Frogger
15 - Spyro
16 - Tekken
17 - Dance Dance Revolution
18 - Need for Speed
19 - Halo
20 - Mario Party
21 - The Sims
22 - Gran Turismo
23 - Pixar
24 - Bejeweled
25 - NBA Live
26 - Dead or Alive
27 - Lineage
28 - Virtua Fighter
29 - Gears of War
30 - Turok
31 - Unreal
32 - Assassin's Creed
33 - Medal of Honor
34 - Crash Bandicoot
35 - Nintendogs
36 - God of War
37 - Metal Gear
38 - Mobile Suit Gundam
39 - Tom Clancy
40 - Street Fighter
41 - Resistance
42 - Mortal Kombat
43 - Rayman
44 - SOCOM
45 - Soul Calibur
46 - Wii
47 - James Bond
48 - Jak and Daxter
49 - Fallout
50 - Ratchet & Clank
51 - Devil May Cry
52 - Rock Band
53 - Doom
54 - Star Wars
55 - Tomb Raider
56 - Brain Age
57 - Lemmings
58 - Prince of Persia
59 - Command and Conquer
60 - Dynasty Warriors
61 - Warcraft
62 - Final Fantasy
63 - SimCity
64 - Doctor Mario
65 - Age of Empires
66 - Guitar Hero
67 - Phantasy Star
68 - Diablo
69 - Mario (Sports)
70 - Starcraft
71 - Half Life
72 - Animal Crossing
73 - Kingdom Hearts
74 - Call of Duty
75 - Banjo-Kazooie
76 - Bomberman
77 - Dragon Quest
78 - Monster Hunter
79 - Tetris
80 - Tales
81 - Ace Attorney
82 - Sonic the Hedgehog
83 - Starfox
84 - Kirby
85 - Castlevania
86 - Mega Man
87 - Donkey Kong
88 - Pokemon
89 - Fire Emblem
90 - Resident Evil
91 - Paper Mario
92 - Pikmin
93 - Mario Kart
94 - Super Smash Bros.
95 - Mario (platformers)

At end of last valid vote (mibuokami):

7 - Legend of Zelda, The
4 - Metroid

Zelda wins? Or voting still open?

I arrived at those results by starting with Final-Fan's post at 21:36 and working forward from there.

The problem comes when supermario128 votes too early. From that point on Mario actually has one less vote than displayed. That means when mibuokami's vote takes Mario to only 1 point, it is actually eliminated. Every vote after that no longer counts.

The problem with that method is that people were voting without knowing the actual scores.

Another problem comes when Final-Fan posts at 22:10. For some reason, he says that mibuokmi's vote is not valid. It looks ok to me, but maybe it was edited at some point.

If voting is still open, and I'm not sure if it is, my vote would be

5 - Legend of Zelda, The (-)(-)
5 - Metroid (+)

I don't think voting should continue and that it should be a three way tie but for the fun.

6 - Legend of Zelda, The (+)

3 - Metroid (- -)

4 - Legend of Zelda, The (--)

4 - Metroid (+)

5 - Legend of Zelda, The (+)

2 - Metroid (- -)

and I close with

6 - Legend of Zelda, The (+)

0 - Metroid (- -)

I hate Zelda

Thats nice, but you're from Canada. Your opinion doesn't count. ;p

A thought on the overall voting - If supermario128 was apparently voting every hour, does that invalidate half of his votes?

No matter, I win because I can beat you all up in a fight AND make a videogame starring you all as cannonfodder ;)  Pwned. hehe