Well as long as we’re submitting anecdotal evidence, here’s mine. I own 16 Wii games, 19 if you count the three VC games I bought.
Wii Sports (Duh)
Wii Play (Mostly for the Remote)
Zelda: Twilight Princess (Naturally)
Tony Hawk Downhill Jam (Impulse Buy)
Trauma Center (Love the hell out of it, dying for TC: New Blood now)
Rayman Raving Rabbids (Got a lot of chuckles out of it, looking into it’s squeal)
Red Steel (I know a lot of people hate it, but I thought it was a blast, beat it three times)
WarioWare (Short, but a ton of fun none the less. Multiplayer was good as well)
Elebits: (Lotta fun, and sorta makes you relive the childhood bliss of making a huge mess. Great Boss fights too.)
Sonic and the Secret Rings (Hard as hell and I loved it. Main game was great, minigames were awful though.)
SSX Blur (First SSX Game. Thought it was great, especially the Uber Tricks. Felt it was the first time a dev used motions controller to make a game more challenging instead of easier.)
Excite Truck (Beat it in a rental, but kept getting urges to keep playing anyways. Bought it and has sense become my personal favorite Wii Game.)
Super Paper Mario (Was pretty good, but I felt it lacked the charm of previous Paper Mario's)
The Godfather (Beat it twice actually, probably the only GTA-esqe game I like more is Vice City itself)
Scarface (IGN said it was better than the Godfather. I thought it was boring as hell. Got 20$ off with my Best Buy Reward Zone Membership.)
Resident Evil 4 (Loved the new cursor aiming. Found myself constantly running out pistol ammo since Shotguns felt clumsy and inaccurate compared to head pops and knifing baddies when they were down.)
Only two I’d say I regretted buying would be Downhill Jam and Scarface. Downhill Jam is actually a pretty good game, but I’m so sour on the THPS series after American Wasteland, that I just couldn’t find it in myself to like it. Scarface on the other hand was just downright boring to me, serves me right for trusting IGN though. Other than that I’m happy with all my other purchases.
I’ve rented plenty of games too. Madden 07 was surprisingly fun, didn’t buy since it I figured 08 would be better. I’d say I got 6$ worth of fun from Spider-man 3. Swinging around with the Wu-Remote/Nunchuck was a lot of fun, it was also the only part of the game that was really much fun, but since I only rented it. Same goes for CoD3, MoH, and Marble Mania, all worth the rentals. Didn’t care for Far Cry or Cooking Mama though.