VERY ASSUMING, the fact that he has a mario avatar and accusing of fanboyism.
As this thread would show, there are a fair share of fors/againsts.
Might as well call the 'fors' fanboys as well.
or you can just grow up.

In terms of the 1P campaign, I think I'm enjoying Battlefield:Bad Company more.

I'm rather surprised.

 He's just a nintendo fanboy jealous of microsoft and sony...

Wonder what would happen if I would make 5 threads bashing SMG. :O

 Do it it's a dum game anyways!

bah, I'll never understand how meeting the RUSSIAN WAR MACHINE OF INFINITE SPAWNING DUMB ENEMIES gives the "feeling of being in the midst of a war." I mean, there were some REALLY GOOD moments in the campaign (the old school mission was probably the best part), but I wonder why people bash JRPG's random battles yet forgive such a poor design choice for a "next gen" shooter.

and, due to my country's servers, I have to play Domination, which features the most stupid "intelligent" respawn system. a quick look at game-monitor shows me 5,000 s&d servers and less than 900 domination servers. I know the game was also design primarly for consoles but still, knowing that usually PC servers are for at least 16 players, I wouldn't mind if they just took out Domination mode :P I also don't think it's all that balanced when you're low level and the only sniper you get is so weak.

that being said, comparing to other PC alternatives, I can say it's definetely overrated, both singleplayer and multiplayer.

the game is great but i have to agree with you man i just dont think its better then halo now thats just my opion and some1 is gonna say my opion is wrong but the real question is why is the cod series going back to world war 2 when they had much better sucess with this game

Yeah you're right, about singleplayer there aren't a lot of other options, besides the two you mentioned I can only think of Ep2, Portal (not exactly the average FPS) and Bioshock can be included as "top tier :P

Half Life 2, Return to Castle Wolfenstien, Deus Ex, System Shock 2, etc. for SP

Counter Strike, Day of Defeat & Team Fortress for MP (Anything from Valve essentially, lol)

Part of the issue I see here is what you prefer... for example I rate a FPS more by SP than MP (as do many others) - while no doubt an equal number of people rate more by MP.

Therefore to me the SP in COD4 is pretty weak compared to Deus Ex, System Shock 2, Half Life 2 (even Crysis has a better SP) and while its MP is very, very good it doesn't eclipse the MP experience of Unreal Tournamt and others.

I also find it disappointing how weak the engine really is in terms of physics and interaction with the environment.

I mean, in the SP campaign they even manage to get away with invisible walls without much criticism - its a little strange your killing machine can't vault a two foot fence...