I've always disliked GTA.

The reason why I disliked 4 is because:

1. The game was repetitive
2. While the gameplay mechanics were much better than previous games, it still wasn't on par with most shooters, thus resulting in gameplay that got boring quick.
3. The majority of the game is pointless
4. I am a Nintendo fan.

THIS^^^^^^

"all hail SONY leader" thread proved it

GTA4 is not a genuine GTA game, it tries too hard to be serious and that just doesn't flow well in Sandbox games. Also, I feel alot of features in it are downright unnecessary like having to bowl with your cousin.

Soul Calibur and Ocarina of Time are worthy of 10's but GTA4.. It's an insult to what a 10 truly represents. 10's are not perfect games, they create the landscape for what a game in general can be. "GTA4 barely moes the lawn."