Both games will receive scores in between 92 to 95%

You're wrong... They will get scores of between 88-92% for both of them to leave room above for the awesomeness of Killzone 2.

Resistance 2 will be the better game,Gears2 will have slightly better reviews mainly because its just overrated imo

Gears of war 2, like 89-94%.
Resistence 2, probably from 85-91%.

I must admit that Resistence 2 keep feeling, and looking, better and better.
Still, Gears of War 2 is a damn beast and it will be releasing on Emergency day II. Goty, believe it!

Oh crap. It was just like old reflexes coming back, i forget about MGS4.
So, imo, the fight is between Gears 2 and MGS4.

Gears will get 97

Res will get 93

resistance 1 sold so lil because the fan base was small! Now its larger it will do amazing.

hmm this one will be a bit tough

resistance 2 will do better bcz the fan base as well as the user base of ps3 has increased.It also looks awesome.

You know what this board needs?

More Resistance 2 vs. Gears 2 threads.