By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Microsoft - What metacritic rating do you think these exclusives will get? Challenge!

Squilliam on 19 August 2008

67% still for metacritic on Too Human with 22 ratings in.



Tease.

Around the Network
shio on 19 August 2008

Left 4 Dead: 91%
Gears 2: 88%
Fable 2: 84%
Banjo: 83%
Infinite Undiscovery: 79%
Last Remnant: 78%
Tales of Verspesia: 76%
Too Human: 69%



http://i48.tinypic.com/120qaon.jpg
Domicinator on 19 August 2008
starcraft said:
Anyone putting Fable 2 at less than 85% is risking my contributor wrath.

*reaches for banhammer*

Wait, WHAT!?! NO BANHAMMER!?!? This job sucks.

 

I didn't even play the first Fable, and I'm crapping myself over Fable 2 based on what I've seen of it so far.  Is Fable 1 worth getting on Xbox Originals?




Barozi on 19 August 2008

The Metacritic understanding of 1UP's scores is ridiculous.
From 1UP:
"Anything we score in the A+ through A- range is considered excellent, B+ through B- is good, C+ through C- is average, D+ through D- is bad, and F is terrible"

C- (average) is a 42/100 ? That grades review system sounds broken in Metacritic.



Squilliam on 19 August 2008
Machina-AX said:
Good to see you updating this thread Squilliam.

Shame it's not guess the IGN score, I would've been bang on with Too Human. I didn't like the demo at all but I thought the critics would be more generous than me. Guuess they aren't.



^^ And you should've added Castle Crashers :P
Thanks! Theres no point in making this thread, get people to make predictions and then just completely ignore it.Castle Crashers is Xbox Live isn't it? Nah its best just to stick with normal releases.

 



Tease.

Around the Network
Squilliam on 23 August 2008

To make it easier, im going to adjust the scoring.

On the mark or 1 point out either side - 5 points.

2-3points out either side - 3 points.

4-5 points out either side 1 points

Score card for Too Human 68% metacritic.

Strategyking - 64% 1 point.

Zexen_lowe 73% 1 point

Gobias 65% 3 points

Mrstickball 75% 0 points

Squilliam 80% 0 points

Ronster 81% 0 points

Saviour X 75% 0 points

Cactus 72% 1 point

Shadowblind 75% 0 points

Jagged Sac Too Human 71% 3 points

 

Machina Ax 78% 0 points

 

Garcian Smith 70% 3 points

 

Jackson50 78% 0 points

 

Riachu 79% 0 points

 

Solojohlo 75% 0 points

 

Bobo012893 71% 3 points

 



Tease.

mrstickball on 23 August 2008

Oh, Squilliam - I read the OP wrong...My post was entirely based off GameRanking scores...Not Metacritic. I don't know how you want to judge that :-p



Back from the dead, I'm afraid.

Squilliam on 23 August 2008
mrstickball said:
Oh, Squilliam - I read the OP wrong...My post was entirely based off GameRanking scores...Not Metacritic. I don't know how you want to judge that :-p

You can repredict. Tales of Vesperia is still open for you today, but Too Human is closed for predictions as its been scored.

Im thinking about adding a few more games, but they have to be well known so i'll think about it a bit later.

 

 



Tease.