I loved it. It really captured that sense of adventure and exploration that I remember feeling playing Zelda games as a kid. The game world is very original and well realized (AKA, not just another boring version of Hyrul), plus the story and how it ties into the original Zeldas is very imaginative, and the cel shading/animation was amazingly well done.

Unfortunately, the distanse between islands was a little far apart for my tastes, the lack of dungeons made it seem a bit easy/shallow, and the fetch quest at the end was lame.

If they could have added a few more dungeons (like two or three) and made the islands about 25% closer to each other that game would have been perfect. As it stands, within the top 3 Zelda games for me (and much better than twilight in my opinion).

If they take out the part of the 8 shards, I'm all right with that...

Pro, although the difficulty level of the game was far too easy. I would also prefer the next Zelda though to be in the Twilight Princess style.

Pro WW my second favourite zelda.

pro

i love the game itself, but i just don't like the cel shading. i really couldn't tell you why, it just doesn't work for me.

i am now pro WW!

happy everybody lol

I liked the graphics, but the game was not very good at the end (the triforce part was tacked on), maybe they should keep the windwaker-like games on the DS for now.

WW is a great game!

I hope the next Zelda features a rowing boat. I want to row like Mario & Sonic at the olymic games! I hope they even make the seas even bigger, it will be a good workout!

i loved windwaker, twilight princess not so much

Windwaker = still best game ever.

I don't particularly want the next Zelda to copy Windwaker, I want it to be awesome in a new way.