Because has a lot of content and is simple & clean

I don't at least not anymore >.> I enjoyed melee a lot though.. maybe it's one of these four things.

1. I over played melee thus brawl seems meh vs wise - but it is an awesome game.
2. I played online and the lag hurts the fun, because offline I wouldn't fall for the same glide upsmash 2x or 3x
3. The game was misprogrammed and sometimes the button presses aren't 1:1 to whats happening on the screen which adds to 2.
4. Maybe I'm just not adapting to he game.

honestly I think it's a combination of 2 and 3 - I can still play melee a lot but brawl is the next step so I try to play that more - the thing is I'm not confused about the physics though they did give my favorite character a right good nerfing by taking out shffling and killing her fair and bair and uair and... But that the buttons on my GC, Wiimote&Nunchuck, CC, or even Wiimote on its side all have a sort of delay on the dodging - even dashing seems a bit off from time to time. I like perfection as far as buttons go and that applies to any game, if the buttons are mapped wrong I deem the game unplayable - in brawls case theirs just a 1/4 second delay - since I like to do dodges within a 1/4 of the opponents attack - that kind of gets me killed - I think that's what killed my like of brawl.

However I still enjoy just going into training mode since I moved over to this area of the world - I don't really know many people and the online component I can only deal with when I have an iron stomach or else I'm afraid I'll kick my wii into the bloodiest of oblivions.

BEcause it's the ultimate fanservice. where else can you beat the hell out of other game icons from different franchises and have fun at the same time?

Because you can have epic battle sessions with the right people. Its all about the MP.

i like it because it is fun, and that's all you need to enjoy a game.

So many reasons it'd be to hard to put in this post. Mainly for the aspect that you are playing as Nintendo/etc characters in a 2d fighter. Filled which man chaotic items that make the game extremly fun and different.

Because when I get frustrated with my brother, i don't need to bitchslap him. I can just bitchslap him in brawl. It's the perfect substitute.

It breaks out of the traditional fighter mold of one vs one with health bars and complicated combos in an arena with little effect on the battle. Instead you get a 4-way fight where you try to knock out your enemies more than they knock you out, arena hazards which have to be avoided (or utilized, heheheh), and items which add a lot of depth and upredictability to the game.