By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - General - What is the colour of water?

Thatmax said:
rajendra82 said:
Thatmax said:
rajendra82 said:
Thatmax said:
^^ water is never pure, there will always be mollecules of other substances in it, even bottled water has minerals and a whole other mess of stuff in it.

 

Not if it's bottled distilled water.  That's about as pure as you'd get.


There is still other particles of minerals in that too, it makes it healthier so taking them out would be stupid.

 

Do you even know what distilled means?  Distillation of water involves boiling the water, then taking the steam and condensing it in a seperate container.  All minerals will be left back in the original container as residue.  Distilled water is not meant for drinking precisely because it has no minerals.  It is meant to be used when highly purified water is necessary for uses like decontamination.  If you drink too much distilled water, you die.

http://www.mercola.com/article/water/distilled_water.htm


From Wiki - "Distillation Gathering water through the use of a bag is a much employed survival technique Gathering water through the use of a pit is another much employed survival technique Distilled water has virtually all of its impurities removed through distillation. Distillation involves boiling the water and then condensing the steam into a clean cup, leaving nearly all of the solid contaminants behind. Distillation produces very pure water but also leaves behind a leftover white or yellowish mineral scale, which requires that the distillation apparatus be frequently cleaned." notice the use of "virtualy"

I was aware that distilled water is "virtually" pure and not "absolutely" pure.  But I had only said, it's about as pure as you get (and of course I meant practically speaking).  While you said, distilled water still has minerals in it because it's healthier that way, and taking them out would be stupid.  Poiniting a small flaw in my statement (if there even was one) does not make the much bigger flaw in your statement disappear.

Distilled bottled water is about as pure as you can get, and if you filled a white tiled indoor swmiing pool with it, the pool bottom would look blueish.  It won't be because the water is impure, or because there is sky reflected in it, ot because of the color of the bottom tiles.  It will be so because pure water actually has a blueish color, which becomes only apparent when there is a tall enough column of it.  Look at the picture posted couple of posts above this, and you can clearly see that a tube of distilled H2O looks blue while that of D2O does not.

 



Around the Network
rajendra82 said:
Thatmax said:
rajendra82 said:
Thatmax said:
rajendra82 said:
Thatmax said:
^^ water is never pure, there will always be mollecules of other substances in it, even bottled water has minerals and a whole other mess of stuff in it.

 

Not if it's bottled distilled water.  That's about as pure as you'd get.


There is still other particles of minerals in that too, it makes it healthier so taking them out would be stupid.

 

Do you even know what distilled means?  Distillation of water involves boiling the water, then taking the steam and condensing it in a seperate container.  All minerals will be left back in the original container as residue.  Distilled water is not meant for drinking precisely because it has no minerals.  It is meant to be used when highly purified water is necessary for uses like decontamination.  If you drink too much distilled water, you die.

http://www.mercola.com/article/water/distilled_water.htm


From Wiki - "Distillation Gathering water through the use of a bag is a much employed survival technique Gathering water through the use of a pit is another much employed survival technique Distilled water has virtually all of its impurities removed through distillation. Distillation involves boiling the water and then condensing the steam into a clean cup, leaving nearly all of the solid contaminants behind. Distillation produces very pure water but also leaves behind a leftover white or yellowish mineral scale, which requires that the distillation apparatus be frequently cleaned." notice the use of "virtualy"

I was aware that distilled water is "virtually" pure and not "absolutely" pure.  But I had only said, it's about as pure as you get (and of course I meant practically speaking).  While you said, distilled water still has minerals in it because it's healthier that way, and taking them out would be stupid.  Poiniting a small flaw in my statement (if there even was one) does not make the much bigger flaw in your statement disappear.

Distilled bottled water is about as pure as you can get, and if you filled a white tiled indoor swmiing pool with it, the pool bottom would look blueish.  It won't be because the water is impure, or because there is sky reflected in it, ot because of the color of the bottom tiles.  It will be so because pure water actually has a blueish color, which becomes only apparent when there is a tall enough column of it.  Look at the picture posted couple of posts above this, and you can clearly see that a tube of distilled H2O looks blue while that of D2O does not.

 


My mistake was mixing up mineral water and distilled water which isnt a huge one. I dont know eneough about the details to get into a whole debate but about the image of the two tubes, it does not prove that with a large eneough amount of the D20 the particles making it appear blue will be eneough in number to reflect blue light. So it doesnt seem like a fair test at all.



The test looked fair to me.  They took two long tubes of equal lengths, filled one with distilled H2O and the other with distilled D2O.  Then they looked at a white paper through both of them.  The chemical properties of both liquids are different, and the paper looked blueish when looked through the H2O filled tube, but still looked white when looked through the D2) filled tube.  That proved that H2O is a slightly blueish liquid, but D2O truly is colorless.  If the tube was longer, the difference in colors would have been more noticeable.  If there was only a small amount of liquid in each tube, the difference in the colors would have been so small, it would be hard to notice, which is why you never can tell this with just a glasss of water.  What's unfair about the test, other than the fact that it shatters the previously held notion that water (in the form of H2O at least) is really a totally colorless liquid.



no colors maybe light blue.



                                     

                             End of 2008 Sales:

               Wii- 39 Million 360- 25Million PS3- 22 Million

                          PSN: papasmurf5721

                  

 

         

 

                                                   

      

If it had NO colour we wouldn't be able to see it.


Not true, it has no color but it bends the light, which results in differences you can see.



Around the Network

yellow.



If we were to see Water molecules on a subatomic level, that might settle this.

If the elements that make up water are colorless how can it make blue?

I know that the properties of Elements are completely altered when another one is added, but it doesn't make sense. Nothing + Nothing = Blue.



Kimi wa ne tashika ni ano toki watashi no soba ni ita

Itsudatte itsudatte itsudatte

Sugu yoko de waratteita

Nakushitemo torimodosu kimi wo

I will never leave you

tombi123 said:
Munkeh111 said:
If in a chemistry exam, you said that H20 is blue, you would receive 0 marks

 

Sorry but GSCE's are bulls**t. If you take chemistry or Physics at college, you will learn that some of the things you were taught at GCSE level are completely wrong.

True.

I was very annoyed to find out that the sequence of shells around atoms (holding electrons) that they teach in GCSE Chemistry is total BS.

We are taught that it goes 2 > 8 > 8 > 18 > 18 etc.... yet at A-level it is 2 > 8 > 18 > 8 > 18..... I was like WTF IS THE POINT IN TEACHING IT WRONG?

(I didn't actually do A-level Chemistry so I may have that wrong... My GCSE Chem teacher told us this about a month before the exams)