According to Brute's (the thread opener) third post, "exclusive" means only on one "console."

Whilst there is a justifiable argument saying this topic can only be decided individually by taste, the only remotely objective measure we have is Gamerankings/Metacritic.

Those two sites say that its the Xbox 360. By far.

As in more than twice the number of high quality exclusives.

As in there isn't really any need for debate.


But of course, there is a legitimate argument to be made for the notion that not even Metacritic/Gamerankings are sufficiently objective for a comparison.

WII. Not for the quality but the diversity of tis library. Too much FPS on PS3/XBOX360. I do like FPS, but I'm not an FPS addict.

Yes I know, but then the list wouldn't look as impressive.

(if i removed all the PC games)

Sales would be another way to measure best exclusives of course.  But would you look at total sales?  Or number of awesome exclusives with high sales?

The issue being that the Wii has a tonne of shovelware exclusives that add up to a fair few sales. 

Actually, Starcraft, according to DMeisterJ's sig, Wii and 360 are tied in terms of exclusives vis a vis metacritic. 360 has more total 90% games (as your sig shows), but as we know a lot of those games aren't exclusives (even console exclusives)

And yeah, Brute said on one "console" but going by what he was referring to, he counted PC as a console. Which is why he said Squilliam's list contains a lot of games that aren't exclusive.

Anyway, it's kind of a dumb thing to get into, since Brute was obviously talking about personal choice. Why try to make it about anything else? One man's pain is another man's pleasure.

Quite easy, 360 first then Wii then PS3.

360 has the most diverse varied games. I would say Wii, but the only exclusives I really like are SMG, SSMB, MKwii. PS3 games that are good are all available on 360. 2 exclusives that are god on Ps3 are MGS4 and Uncharted the rest are Ok. 360 exclusives that are god to awesome are GOW, Halo 3, LO, Forza 2, PGR4, NG2, ES, Mass Effect, Bioshock, Dead Rising. Some people would say 3 of those 360 games are going to PS3 but they are not currently available and havent been for 6- 12 months, so that makes them currently 360 exclusives.

At no point in that post did Brute say that the PC counts as a console.

DMeisterJ, being somewhat fond of Sony, hasn't included 360 console exclusives in his signature......... 

Well as everyone wants to include pc then the games over. Pc wins, by such a large margin that its not even funny. Even the ps2 loses out to the pc. Thats the glory of having one platform for a very long time and having a massive indie scene on top of traditional developers. The pc wins in practically every genre be it RPG, FPS, RTS, TBS, casual. The only subgenre that it really loses out in is JRPG's and modern platformers.

i think its the ps3 this gen and the last gen its the ps3