You can only subtract a point from one character until there are only two characters back, fixing the points and adding my vote in.

Samus 41
Link 29
Mario 25
Luigi 22 (-)
Donkey Kong 21 (-)
Kerrigan 6 (+)

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

Added the rules back in so there's no more confusion

Samus 40 (-)
Link 29
Mario 25
Luigi 22
Donkey Kong 20 (-)
Kerrigan 7 (+)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 1 point from 2 separate characters
3. If there are no characters below 11 points, subtract 10 from all
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

Samus 41 (+)
Link 29
Mario 25
Luigi 22
Donkey Kong 19 (-)
Kerrigan 6 (-)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 1 point from 2 separate characters
3. If there are no characters below 11 points, subtract 10 from all
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

Samus 41
Link 30 (+)
Mario 25
Luigi 22
Donkey Kong 18 (-)
Kerrigan 5 (-)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 1 point from 2 separate characters
3. If there are no characters below 11 points, subtract 10 from all
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

@Blinx -- probably before you started here we stated no more new characters.

Samus 42(+)
Link 30
Mario 25
Luigi 22
Donkey Kong 17 (-)
Kerrigan 4 (-)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 1 point from 2 separate characters
3. If there are no characters below 11 points, subtract 10 from all
4. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

Samus 42
Link 31 (+)
Mario 25
Luigi 22
Donkey Kong 16 (-)
Kerrigan 3 (-)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 1 point from 2 separate characters
3. If there are no characters below 11 points, subtract 10 from all
4. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

Samus 42
Link 31
Mario 24 (-)
Luigi 22
Donkey Kong 17 (+)
Kerrigan 2 (-)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 1 point from 2 separate characters
3. If there are no characters below 11 points, subtract 10 from all
4. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

Samus 43 (+)
Link 31
Mario 24
Luigi 22
Donkey Kong 16(+)
Kerrigan 1 (-)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 1 point from 2 separate characters
3. If there are no characters below 11 points, subtract 10 from all
4. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

Samus 42 (-)
Link 32 (+)
Mario 24
Luigi 22
Donkey Kong 15 (-)
Kerrigan 1

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 1 point from 2 separate characters
3. If there are no characters below 11 points, subtract 10 from all
4. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

Samus 32
Link 23 (+)
Mario 14
Luigi 11 (-)
Donkey Kong 5
Kerrigan 0 (-)

================================================
1. Add 1 point to 1 character
2. Subtract 1 point from 2 separate characters
3. If there are no characters below 11 points, subtract 10 from all
4. No more new characters
================================================

Eliminated
1. Kratos
2. Peach
3. Crash
4. Master Chief
5. Rikku
6. Diablo
7. Tingle
8. Coco
9. Wario
10. Lara Croft
11. Krunch
12. Jak
13. Pac-Man
14. Spyro
15. Gordon Freeman
16. Yoshi
17. Kane
18. Sam Fisher
19. Sora
20. Daxter
21. Rayden
22. Naked Snake
23. Wanda
24. Solid Snake
25. Auron
26. Nathan Hale
27. Ratchet
28. Cecil
29. Kirby
30. Fox (TIE)
30. Tails (TIE)
32. General Edmund Duke
33. Ryu Hayabusa
34. Scorpion
35. Ayane (TIE)
35. Ico (TIE)
37. Davy
38. Alucard
39. Sonic (TIE)
39. Bowser (TIE)
41. Geno
42. Zelda
43. Kefka
44. Midna
45. Megaman

46. Kerrigan