firebush03 said:
Ryuu96 said:
Ironically if us awful ban happy Mods followed the rules to such a strict degree. “Backseat Moderating - You are not a moderator! Use the Report button or contact a moderator via PM if you see anything that needs attention.” You would have been banned multiple times over by now. |
Actually, on that note, I’m curious: Why is “backseat moderating” reason to moderate somebody? It almost comes off to me as, “You are not allowed to voice your opinion against authority on this site. Otherwise, we have reason to ban you.” I feel like this is a good rule to have in place, but the wording is a little vague and thereby broad, creating the adverse effect of collecting people who I do not believe should be banned. (E.g. In a forum discussion problems and solutions for the forum, somebody questions the enforcement of a site rule, so as to potentially dig into a legitimate issue with the site.) Also, FWIW while I do believe the mods can be a tad bit “ban happy” at times (e.g. When I stated how NS2 was showing up PS5, bursting out the gate with DKBananza and MKWorld), it is undeniable that the moderators here exercise a tremendous amount of self-control. With how I engaged in the political forums, for instance, it is shocking that I only ever received a temporary thread ban lol. We also have infamous users such as Hardstuck_Platinum who haven’t seen much any punishment despite being a crystal clear case of “trolling.” Now, do I think more people need be moderated? Well…with how small this site is, I’d say no. Unless you’re looking to accelerate the decline, I think mercy and grace should be exercised at all times. Plus, we are all human. We all make mistakes; sometimes we are just having a really bad day/week/month. I think forgiveness and second chances go a long way. |
I couldn't say the original intentions since that rule has been here since I joined but I imagine it's along the lines of if we allowed it then people would go around publicly in the forms in an attempt to create witch-hunts against certain users, they'd be a lot of "This user should be banned!" in threads and attempt of public pressure instead of simply reporting it, it could be used in clique ways, it also encourages grandstanding. Then of course we also don't want threads dragged off topic by a single user or two complaining about a ban.
As for thread bans, that was my team who introduced those and we introduced those precisely so we didn't need to do full bans, if a user is only an issue in one area then a thread ban solves that issue without banning them from the site entirely, but still people complain as if they'd prefer for us to go back to full bans, Lol. There have been plenty of times I could have banned someone but opted for a thread ban instead. We can use it to remove Xbox trolls or Sony trolls or Nintendo trolls from one section of the site and then they can actually f*cking talk about what they enjoy instead of what they don't 