By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

I recently was taking advantage of the Deals with Gold (couple of years), is that going away, or is that included with the new tier name change?



...to avoid getting banned for inactivity, I may have to resort to comments that are of a lower overall quality and or beneath my moral standards.

Around the Network
Ryuu96 said:
ice said:

Does someone wanna ask Phil why console gamepass is $1 more than PC Gamepass, on top of us being forced to buy the core gamepass to play online? Basically forced to buy gamepass ult (which I have) but this shit makes no sense. Why not just include online in Console GP and have this core shit priced lower lol or even better match PC and make online gaming free since it's the same ecosystem and servers...

I agree that the price differences between Console Game Pass and PC Game Pass should be adjusted but Core Game Pass is literally the exact same price as Xbox Live Gold, nobody is being forced into anything, nothing is changing for most people, Lol.

I'm so baffled by this angry reaction to what is simply a rebranding, my issue is, while I do agree with these complaints, they've been complaints which have existed for years now and only now people are complaining about them. The rebranding when judged on its own seems like (mostly) a good thing to me, with a few adjustments to be made.

At worst, nothing has changed for the consumer, aside from they're losing GWG but in exchange for a collection of 25+ older titles, which will be expanded to overtime (maybe monthly?). For new audiences, this might actually provide more value than the current GWG which is all ancient titles that nobody cared for.

If this was simply called "Xbox Live Core" and instead GWG was swapped for a catalogue of old 1st party titles, would this anger still be the same? Lol. Because that is essentially what this is.

Yes, nothing changes aka console gamers still get shafted 

You need this or GPU to play online

So, like most people that gamepass you want online you either need 

$10 - core + $11 - gamepass console OR $17 for GPU

meanwhile PC gamepass is a dollar cheaper, free online, and even has EA play for $10

Even going the cheapest route console players are still paying 70% more to simply have gamepass+online

This is the same shit situation i've been complaining about



EpicRandy said:

IMO this is a missed opportunity, they should have just ended the gold annual pricing earlier and set it to 4.99/month (Same as annual pricing /12) (Unlike their previous failed attempt at just canceling the annual pricing and leaving it at 9.99) then rise it by 1$ at the same time as the other tier making 5.99$.

Adding all Game Pass titles (at least for 1st party) but with ads (like the rumored tier a while ago) and (1-6) months delay.

It should have instead been named "Live Pass".

They should have also added multiplayer in the standard Game Pass console so that all their offering have live gold benefits but just killed GwG entirely.

now it would have been
Live Pass(ads supported game pass with release delay): 5.99
Game Pass Console: 10.99
Game Pass PC: 10.99
Game Pass Ultimate: 16.99

Don't say the ad word! When that ad supported tier was leaked, it was brutalised online, people always lose their shit whenever ads are mentioned.

I do agree that all 1st party should be added but with a 6-12 month delay, I'm a bit confused why some 1st party titles are missing, I can't work out a pattern right now, but it definitely isn't day one, which it shouldn't be, day one is the incentive for Game Pass Console and Ultimate but it does right now look like a major step down in value from Game Pass Console but still a step up from shitty GWG.

Last edited by Ryuu96 - on 16 July 2023

ice said:
Ryuu96 said:

I agree that the price differences between Console Game Pass and PC Game Pass should be adjusted but Core Game Pass is literally the exact same price as Xbox Live Gold, nobody is being forced into anything, nothing is changing for most people, Lol.

I'm so baffled by this angry reaction to what is simply a rebranding, my issue is, while I do agree with these complaints, they've been complaints which have existed for years now and only now people are complaining about them. The rebranding when judged on its own seems like (mostly) a good thing to me, with a few adjustments to be made.

At worst, nothing has changed for the consumer, aside from they're losing GWG but in exchange for a collection of 25+ older titles, which will be expanded to overtime (maybe monthly?). For new audiences, this might actually provide more value than the current GWG which is all ancient titles that nobody cared for.

If this was simply called "Xbox Live Core" and instead GWG was swapped for a catalogue of old 1st party titles, would this anger still be the same? Lol. Because that is essentially what this is.

Yes, nothing changes aka console gamers still get shafted 

You need this or GPU to play online

So, like most people that gamepass you want online you either need 

$10 - core + $11 - gamepass console OR $17 for GPU

meanwhile PC gamepass is a dollar cheaper, free online, and even has EA play for $10

Even going the cheapest route console players are still paying 70% more to simply have gamepass+online

This is the same shit situation i've been complaining about

Exactly...It's the same situation...Aka nothing to do with Game Pass Core, which is mostly a branding change with the extra perk of a Game Pass catalogue replacing shitty GWG which was causing Xbox bad PR every month, Lol. If this was called Xbox Live Core and they replaced GWG with a collection of old titles, we definitely wouldn't be having this conversation, I think, Lol.

And I do agree with you that the Console/PC situation could be improved but it feels unrelated to this change, it's an issue that has existed for years now, y'all have been paying for Ultimate for years now and I've never seen people so angry about the situation until now, because Xbox Live Gold had a name change, haha.

Like I don't see what is confusing about it, Xbox Live Gold is now being called Game Pass Core and it now has 25+ old titles instead of GWG...Is it exactly what you wanted? Clearly not, but still, Imo, at worst it's a minor upgrade to the current situation, it's the same price as Gold, it's more streamlined into Game Pass marketing and GWG which has been God awful for a long time is being replaced by a better offering.

Last edited by Ryuu96 - on 16 July 2023

Ryuu96 said:
ice said:

Yes, nothing changes aka console gamers still get shafted 

You need this or GPU to play online

So, like most people that gamepass you want online you either need 

$10 - core + $11 - gamepass console OR $17 for GPU

meanwhile PC gamepass is a dollar cheaper, free online, and even has EA play for $10

Even going the cheapest route console players are still paying 70% more to simply have gamepass+online

This is the same shit situation i've been complaining about

Exactly...It's the same situation...Aka nothing to do with Game Pass Core, which is mostly a branding change with the extra perk of a Game Pass catalogue replacing shitty GWG which was causing Xbox bad PR every month, Lol. If this was called Xbox Live Core and they replaced GWG with a collection of old titles, we definitely wouldn't be having this conversation, I think, Lol.

And I do agree with you that the Console/PC situation could be improved but it feels unrelated to this change, it's an issue that has existed for years now, y'all have been paying for Ultimate for years now and I've never seen people so angry about the situation until now, because Xbox Live Gold had a name change, haha.

lol Maybe people were hoping if they made a change it would actually make sense? bruh idgaf what it's called the tiers are shit and make no sense price wise! Core and PC gamepass being priced the same is baffling, this is just dumb lol I will continue to demand better from MS/Xbox



Around the Network
Ryuu96 said:
EpicRandy said:

IMO this is a missed opportunity, they should have just ended the gold annual pricing earlier and set it to 4.99/month (Same as annual pricing /12) (Unlike their previous failed attempt at just canceling the annual pricing and leaving it at 9.99) then rise it by 1$ at the same time as the other tier making 5.99$.

Adding all Game Pass titles (at least for 1st party) but with ads (like the rumored tier a while ago) and (1-6) months delay.

It should have instead been named "Live Pass".

They should have also added multiplayer in the standard Game Pass console so that all their offering have live gold benefits but just killed GwG entirely.

now it would have been
Live Pass(ads supported game pass with release delay): 5.99
Game Pass Console: 10.99
Game Pass PC: 10.99
Game Pass Ultimate: 16.99

Don't say the ad word! When that ad supported tier was leaked, it was brutalised online, people always lose their shit whenever ads are mentioned.

I do agree that all 1st party should be added but with a 6-12 month delay, I'm a bit confused why some 1st party titles are missing, I can't work out a pattern right now, but it definitely isn't day one, which it shouldn't be, day one is the incentive for Game Pass Console and Ultimate but it does right now look like a major step down in value from Game Pass Console but still a step up from shitty GWG.

Yeah it was trashed but it's the kind of thing people get mad about and ... doesn't do anything else because they actually can't, those already on game pass would have nothing changed and those with gold will have the added benefits of access to a free cut down Game Pass with ads making it win-win. So yeah people would cry foul and then proceed to be hypocrites anyway. And better yet, the fake outcry would help publicize the thing lol.

Anyway, that is just a thought on what I think is a great missed opportunity.

One thing is for sure, missing "Live Pass" is unforgivable, what were they thinking?




ice said:
Ryuu96 said:

Exactly...It's the same situation...Aka nothing to do with Game Pass Core, which is mostly a branding change with the extra perk of a Game Pass catalogue replacing shitty GWG which was causing Xbox bad PR every month, Lol. If this was called Xbox Live Core and they replaced GWG with a collection of old titles, we definitely wouldn't be having this conversation, I think, Lol.

And I do agree with you that the Console/PC situation could be improved but it feels unrelated to this change, it's an issue that has existed for years now, y'all have been paying for Ultimate for years now and I've never seen people so angry about the situation until now, because Xbox Live Gold had a name change, haha.

lol Maybe people were hoping if they made a change it would actually make sense? bruh idgaf what it's called the tiers are shit and make no sense price wise! Core and PC gamepass being priced the same is baffling, this is just dumb lol I will continue to demand better from MS/Xbox

Like I don't see what is confusing about it, Xbox Live Gold is now being called Game Pass Core and it now has 25+ old titles instead of GWG...Is it exactly what you wanted? Clearly not, but still, Imo, at worst it's a minor upgrade to the current situation, it's the same price as Gold, it's more streamlined into Game Pass marketing and GWG which has been God awful for a long time is being replaced by a better offering.

Xbox Live Gold and PC Game Pass are already priced the same...This is Xbox Live Gold...With a different name and an upgrade to GWG...



Ryuu96 said:
ice said:

lol Maybe people were hoping if they made a change it would actually make sense? bruh idgaf what it's called the tiers are shit and make no sense price wise! Core and PC gamepass being priced the same is baffling, this is just dumb lol I will continue to demand better from MS/Xbox

Like I don't see what is confusing about it, Xbox Live Gold is now being called Game Pass Core and it now has 25+ old titles instead of GWG...Is it exactly what you wanted? Clearly not, but still, Imo, at worst it's a minor upgrade to the current situation, it's the same price as Gold, it's more streamlined into Game Pass marketing and GWG which has been God awful for a long time is being replaced by a better offering.

Xbox Live Gold and PC Game Pass are already priced the same...This is Xbox Live Gold...With a different name and an upgrade to GWG...

idk why you keep saying people are confused, like where? I never said the prices changed, that's the issue. They should've took the opportunity to restructure the tiers and pricing



ice said:
Ryuu96 said:

Like I don't see what is confusing about it, Xbox Live Gold is now being called Game Pass Core and it now has 25+ old titles instead of GWG...Is it exactly what you wanted? Clearly not, but still, Imo, at worst it's a minor upgrade to the current situation, it's the same price as Gold, it's more streamlined into Game Pass marketing and GWG which has been God awful for a long time is being replaced by a better offering.

Xbox Live Gold and PC Game Pass are already priced the same...This is Xbox Live Gold...With a different name and an upgrade to GWG...

idk why you keep saying people are confused, like where? I never said the prices changed, that's the issue. They should've took the opportunity to restructure the tiers and pricing

Okay, maybe they should have but they didn't.

Still, it's a minor upgrade at worst to the current Xbox Live situation, but you and Angie want to get angry about something which has been the case for years already I've never seen this anger whilst you've both been paying for Ultimate for years already, Lol.

Sigh, Lol. Fine. Feels like a big overreaction to me over what essentially amounts to a branding change but I'll move on, Lol.

Actually I'll stop discussing this entirely, we're not going to agree and I'm not going to say you can't complain about an old situation but clearly we're on two different mindsets about this and how it relates to the current change, Lol.

Last edited by Ryuu96 - on 16 July 2023

EpicRandy said:
Ryuu96 said:

Don't say the ad word! When that ad supported tier was leaked, it was brutalised online, people always lose their shit whenever ads are mentioned.

I do agree that all 1st party should be added but with a 6-12 month delay, I'm a bit confused why some 1st party titles are missing, I can't work out a pattern right now, but it definitely isn't day one, which it shouldn't be, day one is the incentive for Game Pass Console and Ultimate but it does right now look like a major step down in value from Game Pass Console but still a step up from shitty GWG.

Yeah it was trashed but it's the kind of thing people get mad about and ... doesn't do anything else because they actually can't, those already on game pass would have nothing changed and those with gold will have the added benefits of access to a free cut down Game Pass with ads making it win-win. So yeah people would cry foul and then proceed to be hypocrites anyway. And better yet, the fake outcry would help publicize the thing lol.

Anyway, that is just a thought on what I think is a great missed opportunity.

One thing is for sure, missing "Live Pass" is unforgivable, what were they thinking?

You have a point, like with Netflix, everyone bitched hard and...did absolutely nothing, Lol. It wouldn't have affected me on GPU though.

Could you not say though that now, those on Gold have "free" access to a cutdown version of Game Pass, only without the ads?

  • All Old 1st Party Titles (6+ Months Was the Original Rumour IIRC) + Ads
    Vs
  • Some 1st Party Titles (Unknown Timeframe) + No Ads.

Depending on what other titles are added, it might be close enough. We need to learn more about the timeframe and what titles are included and why.

Yeah, I'm starting to think, they should have called it Live Pass, Lol. They want to streamline everything into Game Pass though from a branding perspective and so they can brag about it in the financial. But looking at the reaction here, haha, maybe just keeping the Xbox Live name would have been better, Xbox Live Pass but change GWG to a catalogue of games.

Still, I think they'll have quite a large userbase in Game Pass Core who...

A. Won't even notice the change.

B. Won't even care still.

But they hope some who do notice, will then upgrade to Ultimate, is my assumption, because they're finding difficulty in marketing Game Pass to a casual consumer, Imo, based on anecdotal evidence, Lol. There's probably millions of users still clinging to Xbox Live Gold only just for the multiplayer alone.

Last edited by Ryuu96 - on 16 July 2023