I guess you could say im anticipating R2 since i know it will be good and hyped on KZ2 because i dont know if it will be good.

Read everything that you have quoted here, because you didn't just quote me. Ashoka claimed that GotY was a contest between R2, K2 and MGS4.  You implicitely agreed with him by negating my games but not his.

I have never once declared that any 360 exclusive is "game of the year."  What I have said is that there are many 360 exclusives that are in the running to be game of the year at this point.  Do you disagree?

Fable got GotY from many publications when it came out, and Fable 2 looks even more innovative, do you seriously not even give it a chance?  As for BK3, it is the next installment in what many consider the second best platformer series ever after Mario.

And what standard are you using to compare Too Human and LBP? 

With games like protoype, gta4, mgs4, potentially RE5, SSBB and LBP why would anyone without a complete bias think for a minute that any of those 360 games beyond gears 2 (which i dont see happening) win GOTY. And at any rate who gives a damn what GOTY is, to make your decided console look better?

Game of the eyar is about innovation or something that every one loves(COD4)

here is what I think about game of the year:

the new instalment of star wars on PS3/360( it looks sick,,even though I am not a fan)

GTA(due to its popularity)

Fall out 3

LBP(most innovative title of the year)

some of these might not sell good ,but are true contenders for game of the year

Fable 2 can be nominated for RPG of the year and it has a good chance of wining it,,but not game of the year

Fable 2 could actually be a contender in the innovation category.  Fairly unique RPG drop-in, drop-out co-op, dog AI as a mini-map and gameplay tool, cash earned out of game, financial and experience earnings that co-op players can take back to their own game, and whatever else Molyneux comes up with.

LBP will be innovative, but it's not like the ideas it's using haven't been explored before (if not as deeply as LBP tries too).  Take UT3 and Halo 3's forge for example. 

 I couldn't take your post seriously after that. Just so you know fallout 3 has a dog helper as well and mgs4 has the mk II which is essentially a dog companion if you will. I guess those two games or features dont matter because they are not exclusive to the 360. Then you had to compare LBP to the forge. I think its time you take your fanboy glasses off and pull your head from your ass. Seriously.

A game like Echochrome or maybe even DeBlob would be a runner for innovation. Fable 2? Not so much.

But back on TOPIC, as someone else said, Resistance 2 is a proven game. It should be bigger and better than Resistance 1. It's a no-brainer that it will be good. Unless Insomniac somehow screws it up which I doubt given their track record. Plus, 8-player class based co-op sounds awesome.

Killzone 2 still needs to prove itself. But what footage we've seen so far has been fantastic. Here's hoping that what they show at E3 will be even better.

Wow, this thread turned into an argument about Game of the Year?










... Wiifit. ;D

Resistance 2 is a shoe-in and the co-op mode with the different classes (medic, sniper, etc.) will bring a new dimension of fun to the title, not to mention I'm sure the multiplayer will rule. Killzone 2 I'm not sure of, simply because I have no idea what it plans to do to add to or reinvent the FPS genre. I didn't buy KZ because I had to pick and choose my games sparingly on a limited budget and the reviews didn't seem too good (though my FPS-hating friend loved it). Now I'm waiting to see how it does and learn more about it before I jump on the hype train, though I'm pulling for them to get it right this time.

BK was 2nd best platformer when it was released.

perfect dark was the best console shooter , perfect dark zero was a generic mediocore shooter.

giving rares previous games on the xbox and 360 i wouldnt consider BK3 as a goty contender.

and i think you should seriously consider removing ur head out of microsofts ass