Resistance 2 vs Killzone 2

[starcraft]

SpartanFX said:

starcraft said:

SpartanFX said:

starcraft said:

BCNR34 said:

starcraft said:

Ashoka said:
Although this is just another dopey troll thread it does illustrate how sites like EGM/1Up, Eurogamer, etc will trash Killzone 2. By giving feint praise to R2 they can feel free to trash K2. The bitterness from last year's E3 realtime gameplay demo runs deep in the Xbox fan and media base.

After how amazing Killzone: Liberation was on the PSP and god like graphics and gameplay like this from the real time gameplay demo last E3:

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10589853&postcount=305

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10589035&postcount=277

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10591326&postcount=340

http://www.neogaf.com/forum/showpost.php?p=10578675&postcount=140

K2 will make it a tough choice for GotY 08 between it, R2, and MGS4.

And Fable 2, Gears of War 2, Ninja Gaiden 2, Mario Kart, SSBB and GTAIV..............

And Banjo Kazooie 3, Infinite Undiscovery, Alan Wake and Too Human.........

 

 

Fixed

 

 

lol at teh bolded ones,,,I know you really want them to be game of the eayr but there is no way in hell that either of those games could be the GOTY

 

Yet you would gladly attribute possible GotY status to a title who's predeccessor scored mid-eighties, and even worse Killzone 2, whos predeccessor was just....well....lets not talk about that game.

I admit that MGS4 has a shot, but to say it's between that game, K2 and R2 is ridiculous. As for Banjo, I reckon it will be 90%+, but we'll see. As for Fable 2? RPG of the year, even if it's not GotY.

 

I will be glad if you show me where I have declared game of the year,since I have Never discussed what game will be the GOTY.I anticipate games like KZ2/Geow2 but I don't expect them to be game of the year,,,but you on the other hand declare every single "360 exclusives" as game of the year which is not true at all,,,Little big planet has much higher chance than too human .fable,or BK at being game of the year,but I never declared that as game of the year either ,,,,

cause unlike some people I m not a blind fanboy ,,I see games and I know quality games,,,and I am telling you non of those 3 will have a chance to be the game of the year

Read everything that you have quoted here, because you didn't just quote me. Ashoka claimed that GotY was a contest between R2, K2 and MGS4.  You implicitely agreed with him by negating my games but not his.

I have never once declared that any 360 exclusive is "game of the year."  What I have said is that there are many 360 exclusives that are in the running to be game of the year at this point.  Do you disagree?

Fable got GotY from many publications when it came out, and Fable 2 looks even more innovative, do you seriously not even give it a chance?  As for BK3, it is the next installment in what many consider the second best platformer series ever after Mario.

And what standard are you using to compare Too Human and LBP?