By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - First Super Mario Odyssey Review in! (EDGE)

HyrulianScrolls on 12 October 2017

I really think it might get the coveted 98 on meta.



Around the Network
The Fury on 12 October 2017

Edge giving a game a 10, they give those out like candy nowadays.



Hmm, pie.

Shaunodon on 12 October 2017
RolStoppable said:
tbone51 said:
Do we have a list of the perfect score games?

BotW
SMO
???
List of games with a top 10/10 score
TitlePlatformsIssueYear
Super Mario 64[23] Nintendo 64 E035 1996
Gran Turismo[24] PlayStation E055 1997
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time[25] Nintendo 64 E066 1998
Halo: Combat Evolved[26] Xbox E105 2001
Half-Life 2[27] Windows E143 2004
Halo 3[28] Xbox 360 E181 2007
The Orange Box[29] PlayStation 3, Windows, Xbox 360 E182 2007
Super Mario Galaxy[30] Wii E183 2007
Grand Theft Auto IV[31] PlayStation 3, Windows, Xbox 360 E189 2008
LittleBigPlanet[32] PlayStation 3 E195 2008
Bayonetta[33] PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, Wii U, Windows E209 2009
Super Mario Galaxy 2[34] Wii E215 2010
Rock Band 3[35] PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 E222 2010
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword[36] Wii E234 2011
The Last of Us[37] PlayStation 3 E255 2013
Grand Theft Auto V[38] PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 E259 2013
Bayonetta 2[39] Wii U E272 2014
Bloodborne PlayStation 4 E279 2015
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Nintendo Switch, Wii U E304 2017

 

The Fury said:
Edge giving a game a 10, they give those out like candy nowadays.

20 in 20 years.

If I had to wait an average of one year in between each piece of candy I'd have Gollum levels of withdrawal.



Nuvendil on 12 October 2017
The Fury said:
Edge giving a game a 10, they give those out like candy nowadays.

 

RolStoppable said:
tbone51 said:
Do we have a list of the perfect score games?

BotW
SMO
???
List of games with a top 10/10 score
TitlePlatformsIssueYear
Super Mario 64[23] Nintendo 64 E035 1996
Gran Turismo[24] PlayStation E055 1997
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time[25] Nintendo 64 E066 1998
Halo: Combat Evolved[26] Xbox E105 2001
Half-Life 2[27] Windows E143 2004
Halo 3[28] Xbox 360 E181 2007
The Orange Box[29] PlayStation 3, Windows, Xbox 360 E182 2007
Super Mario Galaxy[30] Wii E183 2007
Grand Theft Auto IV[31] PlayStation 3, Windows, Xbox 360 E189 2008
LittleBigPlanet[32] PlayStation 3 E195 2008
Bayonetta[33] PlayStation 3, Xbox 360, Wii U, Windows E209 2009
Super Mario Galaxy 2[34] Wii E215 2010
Rock Band 3[35] PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 E222 2010
The Legend of Zelda: Skyward Sword[36] Wii E234 2011
The Last of Us[37] PlayStation 3 E255 2013
Grand Theft Auto V[38] PlayStation 3, Xbox 360 E259 2013
Bayonetta 2[39] Wii U E272 2014
Bloodborne PlayStation 4 E279 2015
The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild Nintendo Switch, Wii U E304 2017

You were saying, Fury?  Cause looking at this they gave one in 2011, zero in 2012, two in 2013, one in 2014, one in 2015, zero in 2016, and so far two in 2017.  Do enlighten us as to when this famously reliable and tough reviewer went soft and started handing out these 10s with such abandon.

It's amazing how Edge's reputation as a hardass was virtually unchallenged...before Breath of the Wild got a 10.



The Fury on 12 October 2017
Shaunodon said:

20 in 20 years.

If I had to wait an average of one year in between each piece of candy I'd have Gollum levels of withdrawal.
Nuvendil said:

You were saying, Fury?  Cause looking at this they gave one in 2011, zero in 2012, two in 2013, one in 2014, one in 2015, zero in 2016, and so far two in 2017.  Do enlighten us as to when this famously reliable and tough reviewer went soft and started handing out these 10s with such abandon.

It's amazing how Edge's reputation as a hardass was virtually unchallenged...before Breath of the Wild got a 10.

5 in their first 14 years. 15 in the last 10. My point still stands.

Like candy, I tells ya.



Hmm, pie.

Around the Network
Jranation on 12 October 2017
The Fury said:
Edge giving a game a 10, they give those out like candy nowadays.

No they aren't lol xD



Pocky Lover Boy! 

Peh on 12 October 2017

Game of the year...this will be a death battle between Zelda and Mario.
The DLC for Zelda is still on its way.



Intel Core i7 8700K | 32 GB DDR 4 PC 3200 | ROG STRIX Z370-F Gaming | RTX 3090 FE| Crappy Monitor| HTC Vive Pro :3

fedfed on 12 October 2017

this is amazing! I am so happy!



Switch!!!

asfasfasf on 12 October 2017

another great 10/10
meanwhile ps4 - no mans sky 1/10 LAMO



GuyDuke on 12 October 2017
Peh said:
Game of the year...this will be a death battle between Zelda and Mario.
The DLC for Zelda is still on its way.

Yeah, what's happening with that btw? Holidays are like... very close and we know nothing of it.