6 - 1 vote: Earthbound

4 - 3 votes: The Wonderful 101, Resident Evil Revelations

TOP 3

6 - 1 vote: Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker

5 - 3 votes: Hyrule Warriors

4 - 5 votes: Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze

TOP 3

6 - 1 vote: Fast Racing Neo, The Binding Of Isaac: Rebirth

4 - 2 votes: Captain Toad: Treasure Tracker

TOP 3

6 - 1 vote:  Mario & Sonic at the Rio 2016 Olympic Games

5 - 2 votes: Star Fox Zero

4 - 5 votes: Paper Mario: Color Splash

TOP 3

2012: NintendoLand
2013: Super Mario 3D World
2014: Super Smash Bros Wii U
2015: Xenoblade X
2016: Tokyo Mirrage Sessions #FE

Hot DANG that 2015 race was TIGHT. Both games are excellent, but Xenoblade Chronicles X gets it for the substance for me.

Edit:  Ooooh and now they're tied!

Sorry, this post didn't enter my count  It would've tied the 2015 GOTY!

Anyway, if somebody wants tocontinue the tally (if more people continue voting) feel free, since I won't have time in the near future to do it!

Some things that have surprised me have been:

- The lack of votes for Rayman Legends, Lego City Undercover and Monster Hunter in 2013, I guess that SM3DW was too strong for them!
- Only 3 votes for Super Mario Maker. I didn't expect it to win, but I thought it would be more popular.
- Also, didn't expected TMS to win the GOTY by a landslide, although it's true it didn't have a lot of competition.

Why havent you put Deus Ex on 2013? It has at least two votes!

I take it your just counting first picks and not runners up?

Splatoon over XenoX?