Eh. This is microsofts strongest month in their strongest territory and they have all this momentum from the xb1s. They basically just hit a wall running, now that the Pro is out. The paradigm will return back to normal at the very least until Scorpio comes out moving forward.  What are you gonna say when ps4 takes the next 9+ NPDs in a row?

So if the PS4 only won November because of the Pro, what do you think helped the X1 win some of those months? It's not it like the X1 was just coasting along and took 4 months. 

Eh, let's also look at what released the last time we had Slim Models. For the PS3, it was Uncharted 2 and Modern Warfare 2. The 360S released with Halo Reach and the original Black Ops. All of these were high quality, system pushing, critically acclaimed games. 

The PS4 Slim + Pro and X1S have Gears 4 (brilliant, but not on that caliber), Infinite Warfare (another title that's decent enough, but no Modern Warfare 2), and The Last Guardian (love you, Ueda, but this was never going propel the PS4 into the Heavens).

To me, things don't look too bad.

Name three users and maybe I'll see what I can do. Of course that has its price...

Blasted? No. I see people disagreeing with you. Nothing wrong with that.

To the topic, yes, that's my point. They tried really hard to win those months, where Sony didn't really do much (and didn't have to, it's a mere 4 NPDs and they're still leading in the country by over a million units).

One won't know what would have happened until we are back in the off months of Jan-August.

Now let's take a close look at that:

• Battlefield 1 - Fantastic game. Yes. Not much of a system mover, however.
• WATCH_DOGS 2 - Speaks for itself. Sold less than the original and wasn't accompanied by the same hype.
• Titanfall 2 - As of now, it's selling worse than the original and was never going to contribute and major amount to the units sold of either console.
• Dishonored 2 - Isn't a huge franchise like that.
• Mafia III - While gamers seemed to like it, the game was critically injured, which usually cuts off any kind of legs for console sales.
• Skyrim Remastered - May have moved some units, but nothing even close to the caliber of a Modern Warfare or some other major title. TES: VI will do that.

As for what's up YoY, we don't have solid numbers. So it's pointless to make any full assertions based on one unconfirmed source. You'll have a better idea next month.

Idk seems like making excuses

The combination of Call of Duty, Battlefield, Watch Dogs, Titanfall, Dishonored, Mafia along with first holiday for Slim models and sub-$250 price tags should have put them up YOY.

As for the rumored figures, you should read the post that I originally responded to. He asked why the rumored numbers are considered bad, I said they arent bad but are lower than people thought they would be based on all the things they had going for them.