I don't think your support of Mr. P really warrants us questioning you until we learn his full alignment.

Think of it like this, whatever our assumed odds are with Mr. P being non town (I'd say I'm about 70/30), we then theoretically have a 70% chance of lynching scum.

You now start backing up Mr. P. Backing somebody up by no means inherently means you are teamed with him, so no matter what, the odds won't be nearly as high as they are for Mr. P. Why sidetrack people with additional scummy behavior when it is, quite frankly, time for us to get on the same path and make a decision.

I think much more will come from questioning this after we see a result.

70% : - D : - D : - D. You'd think with all the proof I've given it will at least be 50/50.

Vote: Mr.P

I don't fucking care anymore

It's day 1. How much are you going to car eby day 5 (Possibly)? That's even more destructive behaviour than mine. Do take me out of my misery though.

Maybe I'm just imagining things, but I just feel like this mrp lynch is just too convenient.

I'd rather lynch someone like clyde or noctis. The group thinks mr.p is well deserving of a lynch for a bunch of things he's said. I think he's just a noob and made some mistakes. He seems genuine.

I think the guys hanging out on the sidelines are worth a vote. If you look at their posts, there's a vacuum. You won't find anything. Meanwhile, I think everyone here has said at least a couple of suspicious things. We could really build a case against anyone.

Maybe it's better to just take a shot into the vacuum.

This is actually what I was offering points for. "Don't know why this guy never gets lynched." and "he never gets lynched it's just no [fair], how does he go under the radar so much?" I've voiced my concern about Xander playing when it seems he's never actually active, but I see no reason to whine that he wasn't being lynched. Feels more like scum to me upset that he gets called out while someone else doesn't, rather than a townie concerned about scum going unnoticed.

And I have to apologize for not looking for exactly how the Stefl/darwin relationship went down while I re-read, I was working on postals(post-totals) while going through and forgot I was supposed to be looking until I came upon the discussion by prof already. Will look for that specifically tonight after raid(will post while I can between pulls) or tomorrow after work, before deadline.

You seemed pretty interested in having a lynch toDay earlier. What changed?

Also, you seemed to be suspicious of Mr.P before. Why the new viewpoint?

http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8156597
http://gamrconnect.vgchartz.com/post.php?id=8158060

Mayhaps I missed some posts, but I wouldn't consider you to have been defending him, and certainly not as much as you say.

All signs are pointing to he's not playing as if he thought he's got such a powerful town role and can't be killed by scum.
No scumhunting beyond throwing names out, seemingly at random since there's no explanation for them when asked.
Offered to sacrifice himself.

Then there's the weak defenses.
~"Totally proven confirmed town."
~"Too scummy to be scum."

Wait, the Day is still going? Damn, I wish I'd hopped on the second I could!

Who all is here right now other than Linkz and me?