By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Gaming - your controversial opinion about "one of the best games ever made"

onionberry on 10 November 2016

JWeinCom said:
I don't like Dark Souls. I feel like the game doesn't want me to play it, and that's fine by me.

I think Skyrim is just boring. The game kept me mildly engaged for 20 hours or so, but then I realized I wasn't having any fun.
fair
I like 3D Sonic games more than the 2D ones.
I like sonic lost world
I really didn't like Majora's mask. Not a fan of the time system.
you're a sinner
Super Mario 2 USA is waaay better than the Japanese one.
Never played the japanese version
Mega Man 9 and 10 are better than 3.
never played any megaman game before megaman x

The Uncharted games are just good. Not great. Forgettable fun.

I agree for the most part, but uncharted 2 is a masterpiece


Around the Network
onionberry on 10 November 2016
onionberry said:

JWeinCom said:
I don't like Dark Souls. I feel like the game doesn't want me to play it, and that's fine by me.

I think Skyrim is just boring. The game kept me mildly engaged for 20 hours or so, but then I realized I wasn't having any fun.

fair
I like 3D Sonic games more than the 2D ones.

I like sonic lost world

I really didn't like Majora's mask. Not a fan of the time system.

you're a sinner

Super Mario 2 USA is waaay better than the Japanese one.

Never played the japanese version

Mega Man 9 and 10 are better than 3.

never played any megaman game before megaman x

The Uncharted games are just good. Not great. Forgettable fun.

I agree for the most part, but uncharted 2 is a masterpiece


Fei-Hung on 10 November 2016
StarOcean said:
onionberry said:

fallout 3 is very special to me because that game was my first "western open world" experience, although I like the formula of those games I understand the flaws

Yeah, idk. I couldn't get into it. It's just boring to me. Nothing about it really stands out to me. Fallout 1 and 2 are pretty good though

 

Never played the originals, but I feel the same way about all of Bethesda's games. They certainly give me my money's worth in game time, but the stories and quests are mostly forgettable. The combat is nothing to write home about, but like many addictive games, they have a hook. In terms of story and quests I preferred TW3 in every way.

onionberry on 10 November 2016
BraLoD said:
Super_Boom said:

My favorite game ever is Fire Emblem: Path of Radiance, which not only sold poorly, but is part of a genre that isn't known for amazing meta-scores.

If we're talking about other people's favorite games, I have a tough time enjoying the Uncharted games. The story and graphics are amazing, and I enjoy the parkour elements...but the gunplay has never felt very fun to me.

Probably not as controversial, but though I loved Persona 4, there are games in its own frachise I enjoyed much more.

P3 is better than P4, let the world come after us xP

in this we can agree and we can kiss 



onionberry on 10 November 2016
Fei-Hung said:
StarOcean said:

Yeah, idk. I couldn't get into it. It's just boring to me. Nothing about it really stands out to me. Fallout 1 and 2 are pretty good though

 

Never played the originals, but I feel the same way about all of Bethesda's games. They certainly give me my money's worth in game time, but the stories and quests are mostly forgettable. The combat is nothing to write home about, but like many addictive games, they have a hook. In terms of story and quests I preferred TW3 in every way.

it's funny because I love the side quests of fallout 4 more than the side quests of the witcher 3, but the main quest of the witcher 3 was more interesting than the main quest on fallout 4. And to me, doomed boston was more interesting than velen and all the other areas.



Around the Network
Fei-Hung on 10 November 2016
onionberry said:
Fei-Hung said:

 

Never played the originals, but I feel the same way about all of Bethesda's games. They certainly give me my money's worth in game time, but the stories and quests are mostly forgettable. The combat is nothing to write home about, but like many addictive games, they have a hook. In terms of story and quests I preferred TW3 in every way.

it's funny because I love the side quests of fallout 4 more than the side quests of the witcher 3, but the main quest of the witcher 3 was more interesting than the main quest on fallout 4. And to me, doomed boston was more interesting than velen and all the other areas.

 

Agree on that. FO4 I think has more character in a lot of the areas (children of atom area, the coast, the school, asylum etc), but I found the quests themselves more varied in TW3. They both have their own pro's and cons I suppose. Neither can beat Yakuza though :p

Volterra_90 on 10 November 2016

I totally forgot about Elder Scrolls and Fallout games. Both have similar isssues. Awkward and boring gameplay, hilariously bad dialogues, some side quests are cool but the main plot is... shitty at best.

Also, what the hell was wrong with Fallout 4 audio? I mean, the voices sounded with an unbelievable low quality xD.



hershel_layton on 10 November 2016
onionberry said:

Ok so we have a lot of "this is the best game or this isone of the best games ever made" Maybe the game is indeed one of the best games ever, but your opinion is very different and that's ok...

I'm first, of course... mine is... Shadow of the colossus, I understand why people love the game, but imho the game is not that good. Besides the climbing mechanic, the gameplay is subpart, the soundtrack was good and the "story"?? is intriguing??? if you do some research I guess.

 Maybe because I played the game a year ago, same thing happends with a lot of people that play ocarina of time now, they say "the game is not that good and not even the best zelda game" because they play the game 18 years later and they don't see the wow factor. But I'm not sure about my "I played the game too late" opinion because a game like Cave Story is one of the best games ever made for me. 

I understand that shadows of the colossus is all about emotion when you're figthing the bosses and exploring the landscapes, and I won't lie, it's super emotional and artistic but for me is not enough to say "one of the best games ever"

Mention the game and why the game is good, not that good or even bad, in your opinion.

Finally , another person who understands the greatness of cave story.

 

I'll admit that I own the pc, 3ds, and wii version 😂 completely worth it. the creator shows that anyone can make a game if the work hard enough 



 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

12/22/2016- Made a bet with Ganoncrotch that the first 6 months of 2017 will be worse than 2016. A poll will be made to determine the winner. Loser has to take a picture of them imitating their profile picture.

hershel_layton on 10 November 2016
Kuksenkov said:
I can't stand Zelda Wind Waker, played it many years ago and found it very boring. I couldn't get behind the silent world and how ugly the characters were. I couldnttget into the combat either, and listening to Link drives me nuts.

"HYAAA HOOOO KAAA HAAAAA" ~link 



 

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

12/22/2016- Made a bet with Ganoncrotch that the first 6 months of 2017 will be worse than 2016. A poll will be made to determine the winner. Loser has to take a picture of them imitating their profile picture.

onionberry on 10 November 2016
hershel_layton said:
onionberry said:

Ok so we have a lot of "this is the best game or this isone of the best games ever made" Maybe the game is indeed one of the best games ever, but your opinion is very different and that's ok...

I'm first, of course... mine is... Shadow of the colossus, I understand why people love the game, but imho the game is not that good. Besides the climbing mechanic, the gameplay is subpart, the soundtrack was good and the "story"?? is intriguing??? if you do some research I guess.

 Maybe because I played the game a year ago, same thing happends with a lot of people that play ocarina of time now, they say "the game is not that good and not even the best zelda game" because they play the game 18 years later and they don't see the wow factor. But I'm not sure about my "I played the game too late" opinion because a game like Cave Story is one of the best games ever made for me. 

I understand that shadows of the colossus is all about emotion when you're figthing the bosses and exploring the landscapes, and I won't lie, it's super emotional and artistic but for me is not enough to say "one of the best games ever"

Mention the game and why the game is good, not that good or even bad, in your opinion.

Finally , another person who understands the greatness of cave story.

 

I'll admit that I own the pc, 3ds, and wii version 😂 completely worth it. the creator shows that anyone can make a game if the work hard enough 

<3