By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sales Discussion - Amazon U.S. October bestsellers and general Amazon-based discussion

Dark_Feanor said:
Battlefield 1 stats shows a stronger Xbox One usage compared to 4 and Hardline.

http://bf1stats.com/

http://bf4stats.com/

I think it is hard to belive it´s not moving consoles.

Has it been on EA access?



 

The PS5 Exists. 


Around the Network
GribbleGrunger said:
Dark_Feanor said:
Battlefield 1 stats shows a stronger Xbox One usage compared to 4 and Hardline.

http://bf1stats.com/

http://bf4stats.com/

I think it is hard to belive it´s not moving consoles.

Has it been on EA access?

Since the 13th, yes. 



Dark_Feanor said:
Battlefield 1 stats shows a stronger Xbox One usage compared to 4 and Hardline.

http://bf1stats.com/

http://bf4stats.com/

I think it is hard to belive it´s not moving consoles.

We know you like Xbox, but I would like you to check back in and let us know how much more people are playing the game on PS4 when the game launches for real on the 21st. Also, it would be nice to see you point out the reason as to why the Xbox One version is that high in the first place, but I'll just do it for you. Battlefield 1 is free on EA Access to play for 10 hours before launch, so we got some skewed numbers there. 

 

Also, unless I'm losing my mind, it actually says that the PS4 version has about 5,000 more people playing currently

PC: 56,070 (24h peak: 64,575)

XBOXONE: 78,430 (24h peak: 124,684)

PS4: 83,003 (24h peak: 94,229)

Total: 217,503



bluedawgs said:
Dark_Feanor said:
Battlefield 1 stats shows a stronger Xbox One usage compared to 4 and Hardline.

http://bf1stats.com/

http://bf4stats.com/

I think it is hard to belive it´s not moving consoles.

We know you like Xbox, but I would like you to check back in and let us know how much more people are playing the game on PS4 when the game launches for real on the 21st. Also, it would be nice to see you point out the reason as to why the Xbox One version is that high in the first place, but I'll just do it for you. Battlefield 1 is free on EA Access to play for 10 hours before launch, so we got some skewed numbers there. 

 

Also, unless I'm losing my mind, it actually says that the PS4 version has about 5,000 more people playing currently

PC: 56,070 (24h peak: 64,575)

XBOXONE: 78,430 (24h peak: 124,684)

PS4: 83,003 (24h peak: 94,229)

Total: 217,503

Well, well, well.

It seems text interpretation is not your strenght.

I clearly said "COMPARED TO 4 AND HARDLINE". It´s also prime time in Europe with has a almoste 3 to 1 ratio in favor of the PS4.

The EA access is up since last Thuesday. Which, in fact you can get Hardline for free.

More, what about Battlefront? http://swbstats.com/

Last year the EA access didn´t pushed XOne user base that much IIRC.



Dark_Feanor said:
bluedawgs said:

We know you like Xbox, but I would like you to check back in and let us know how much more people are playing the game on PS4 when the game launches for real on the 21st. Also, it would be nice to see you point out the reason as to why the Xbox One version is that high in the first place, but I'll just do it for you. Battlefield 1 is free on EA Access to play for 10 hours before launch, so we got some skewed numbers there. 

 

Also, unless I'm losing my mind, it actually says that the PS4 version has about 5,000 more people playing currently

PC: 56,070 (24h peak: 64,575)

XBOXONE: 78,430 (24h peak: 124,684)

PS4: 83,003 (24h peak: 94,229)

Total: 217,503

Well, well, well.

It seems text interpretation is not your strenght.

I clearly said "COMPARED TO 4 AND HARDLINE". It´s also prime time in Europe with has a almoste 3 to 1 ratio in favor of the PS4.

The EA access is up since last Thuesday. Which, in fact you can get Hardline for free.

More, what about Battlefront? http://swbstats.com/

Last year the EA access didn´t pushed XOne user base that much IIRC.

Yes, and you failed to point out why it has a stronger usage, which is the fact that it is the highest profile game released on EA Access and its free to play before launch, and you then went on to say because of that it is "hard to believe it's not moving consoles." EA Access is not available on the PS4, therefore the only people who are playing it on PS4 are the people who bought the more expensive early enlister edition, while the Xbox One version has many people playing it for free who already own the console along with the early enlister edition and it's still below the PS4 version. Hardline, which sold a fraction of what Battlefield 1 will sell, came out in early 2015, when EA Access obviously had much less people subscribed to it. Doesn't seem stronger to me, just seems like it has better circumstances currently to make it appear that way to you.



Around the Network

You only can compare BF1 this weekend when the game fully releases, i total expect Ps4 to destroy both Pc and Xbox in raw numbers but maybe Xbox can surprise me, after all is the Shooter Console of last gen and i bet many millions who moved from 360 was because of that.



bluedawgs said:
Dark_Feanor said:

Yes, and you failed to point out why it has a stronger usage, which is the fact that it is the highest profile game released on EA Access and its free to play before launch, and you then went on to say because of that it is "hard to believe it's not moving consoles." EA Access is not available on the PS4, therefore the only people who are playing it on PS4 are the people who bought the more expensive early enlister edition, while the Xbox One version has many people playing it for free who already own the console along with the early enlister edition and it's still below the PS4 version. Hardline, which sold a fraction of what Battlefield 1 will sell, came out in early 2015, when EA Access obviously had much less people subscribed to it. Doesn't seem stronger to me, just seems like it has better circumstances currently to make it appear that way to you.

Ok, we will talk more in one and a half day.

But I urge you not to overreach my points. I was very clear in my first post: BF1 is, for now, doing realy great on the XOne. 

There is no reason to belive that the Xone after 3 months up YoY, would have a steep drop on the month of Gears 4, Battlefield, Titanfall and others.



bluedawgs said:
Dark_Feanor said:

Well, well, well.

It seems text interpretation is not your strenght.

I clearly said "COMPARED TO 4 AND HARDLINE". It´s also prime time in Europe with has a almoste 3 to 1 ratio in favor of the PS4.

The EA access is up since last Thuesday. Which, in fact you can get Hardline for free.

More, what about Battlefront? http://swbstats.com/

Last year the EA access didn´t pushed XOne user base that much IIRC.

Yes, and you failed to point out why it has a stronger usage, which is the fact that it is the highest profile game released on EA Access and its free to play before launch, and you then went on to say because of that it is "hard to believe it's not moving consoles." EA Access is not available on the PS4, therefore the only people who are playing it on PS4 are the people who bought the more expensive early enlister edition, while the Xbox One version has many people playing it for free who already own the console along with the early enlister edition and it's still below the PS4 version. Hardline, which sold a fraction of what Battlefield 1 will sell, came out in early 2015, when EA Access obviously had much less people subscribed to it. Doesn't seem stronger to me, just seems like it has better circumstances currently to make it appear that way to you.

Actually for BF1 with EA/Origin you can only get 10 hours free and since it was available since the 13th most people probably used the 10 hours.



jason1637 said:
bluedawgs said:

Yes, and you failed to point out why it has a stronger usage, which is the fact that it is the highest profile game released on EA Access and its free to play before launch, and you then went on to say because of that it is "hard to believe it's not moving consoles." EA Access is not available on the PS4, therefore the only people who are playing it on PS4 are the people who bought the more expensive early enlister edition, while the Xbox One version has many people playing it for free who already own the console along with the early enlister edition and it's still below the PS4 version. Hardline, which sold a fraction of what Battlefield 1 will sell, came out in early 2015, when EA Access obviously had much less people subscribed to it. Doesn't seem stronger to me, just seems like it has better circumstances currently to make it appear that way to you.

Actually for BF1 with EA/Origin you can only get 10 hours free and since it was available since the 13th most people probably used the 10 hours.

Okay i don't have proof of whether or not people used their 10 hours already but i'm gonna declare that as total bullshit. People who aren't hardcore gamers don't usually play 10 hours of a game in that short of a time period, also you're basically saying everyone who has EA Access downloaded it on the first day, and not any other day since then. By the way, you know EA Access will continue to get more subs everyday right? Which means more people will be downloading Battlefield 1 with that new subscription



bluedawgs said:
Titanfall on PS4 has to start moving

Yeah, what gives on that? It's not like it's a Mass Effect thing where people not having the first game put people off the series on Sony platforms. I mean, you don't need to play the first Titanfall to "get it".