Just because Amazon isn't 100% accurate and the difference between the PS4 & XB1 was small according to Zhuge?

No

Guess it isnt flawless... 1 month wrong out of almost 3 years worth... still pretty good.

I'm not saying the charts are wrong per se.

But some of you are not taking into consideration the relative position of all consoles - because, any thing below 30's is realy close - and forgeting the monthly charts.

It's over, lets all pack up and go home. It had a good run, never to be tagged again. That'll teach us all, or something like that :)

Not one tiny bit. If I backed horses and a friend of mine had been giving me tips on the winner every month for three years and he was right every single time, I wouldn't refuse to take his advise simply because he got it wrong ONCE. That would be idiotic.

I'm more than happy to see anyone's opinions and thoughts in the Amazon thread but if this leads to regular daily 'trolling', I will report it. This has been a great thread every month and largely a pleasant and friendly experience.

Maybe I remembering wrong but I'm pretty sure most people said it would be close. No need to blow your load because you said Xbox would win. We see guys like you every month, even a broken clock is right twice a day. 

Anyway, even though Amazon showed a close month it did have PS4 edging it. 

That was the PS4 Pro at the top. It's not out yet.

I doubt it.  They both will most likely have $249 SKUs for BF, though I think Sony will benefit more from that price point.  The XBO already has plenty of OG bundles at that price.  You also have Pro coming in Nov, which should lead to a large lead for Nov NPD and most likely for Dec, too.  PSVR is off to a good start, if it can continue decently thoughout the next 2 months, it should help some, as well.

Again?!  Wow, that bundle has not done well, at all.  I thought you were going to be right in it climbing up the charts, but here it is 8 days from release and it is sitting at #111.  On Gamestop, 6 XBO SKUs, including 4 OG SKUs, are selling better than it.

everybody wants a ps4 pro... i wonder if its gonna be the same when scorpio comes out

XBO just dropped to #100. Wonder if it'll be pushed out of the Top 100 in the next update. Of course, sales for it are probably staying constant, just many other things are selling better.