Kanye West: Makes great music. People hate him because of his persona
Justin Bieber: Girls loved him so it became cool to hate him.
The Force Awakens: A capable film but nitpicked to hell!
Batman V Superman: Another film that's a hit with certain audiences but totally brutalized by others
Tomb Raider 2013: A change in direction that resulted in huge sales but is hated by some fans of the older style.
Xbox One: almost ushered in a new age of DRM (not really. It just wouldn't have sold), mandatory Kinect, and sub 1080p gaming at a time when everything was 1080p or above
Uncharted 3: Uncharted 2 raised the bar so much that people were disappointed with Uncharted 3.
Or is there something else that I'm forgetting?