There are some years where there is a clear cut winner that everyone agrees on. This was not one of those years. 

Yes! They were awesome! 

I won! I got to see and probably play a lot of great games in the near future yeah!

Yo mama, cause she's so fat you couldn't see any of the conferences.

Sony was the best, but this is probably one of the worst E3's in a while. Nothing excited me at all.

The orchestra didn't really go with the conference and the audience was so unclassy, so it felt kind of odd watching them.  

EA: Too much tell, not enough show. Still more 'wait for more' stuff is BS, but EA Originals is nice. C+
Beth: Alright conference with a few cool reveals hampered by those hired cheeleaders. B-
MS: Simultaneously the best and worst time to buy an XBO. Good presentation, though. B
Ubi: Great energy, good reveals, Trey and Matt stole the show, underwhelmed by their surprise this year. B+
PC: Started well but really fizzled out by the second half. Loved Bannerlord's siege gameplay, though. C
Sony: All Killer No Filler. They've done it again. A.

Winner: Sony by a good margin. Not the best E3 over all, but don't tell them that.

I guess at this point Sony by default as none have really impressed. Why is everyone losing their minds over more remasters?

This E3 is mostly getting a "meh" grade from me.

Sony imo, not entirely just because of the games with none of the BS other then skylanders showing itself for a few seconds.

I really like that instead of having the typical stage lit up with tons of lights it was classy, the orchestra really added to the atmosphere. Not only did Sony not do any BS but some games were cut from the show, they put everything into best games highlight reel it seemed like. I did not even guess Call of Duty was Call of Duty at first either. I'm guessing the skylander was part of w/e deal Sony struck with Activation involving Crash remasters to make it into the main stage they moved on quickly from it. Oh and at the end of the conference Sony literally put up a table of games and dates weather they were just in development releasing this year or next. I really liked that openness.

In other words the conference just felt powerful beginning to end outside what I mentioned. All other conferences had many ups and downs. Microsoft had a good conference but it absolutely felt weaker to me. Scorpio due to the script strikes me as something they added recently. The "specs" are quite literally not set in stone in the wording. My guess is knowing Sony had Res7 and Call of Duty along with their own God of War and Horizon may have made Microsoft pull that trigger. Not that an announcement is bad, it just seemed unpolished with several lines repeated showing a sign of a rush job (just my opinion, okay?).

I also would like to mention that the PC conference wasn't god awful this year like it was last year. It was actually pretty good, nothing to write home about though. Like to note I primarily play on PC. The show wasn't special but easily most improved.

Everyone agree that EA was horrible I'm guessing?

Yeah, give it to Sony.

Sony 8/10

MS 7/10

Bethesda 6.5/10

Ubisoft Unfinished/10 (I lost interest in the end)

EA didn't watch.