shikamaru317 said:
Ganoncrotch said:
So the only real issue is that people on the internet who downloaded something... are complaining about it, I don't see the issue. Ignore them, problem solved, it if was people who were never going to make use of the mods on the platform that the person was creating them for originally or ever (the PC) then what difference does it make to the modder if someone has a cry that the mod they created for the PC isn't working on the X1 correctly, if this was such a big issue then it could be solved by knowledge of the issue at hand, nothing more needs to happen really.
|
Yeah, basically the mod creators just need to learn to ignore the whiners. Instead some of them are letting the complaining get to them, and those are the ones creating the drama here it seems.
|
It's not the whining that's the issue. They've learned to ignore whiners. Shoot, I was part of one of the largest and most positively viewed modding teams for Skyrim and even we had some absolute dicks come by from time to time. We even had someone outright steal our work. And we were MERP for goodness sake. Other mods get constant whining and non stop pestering from people who don't read readme files. The modding community has whiners out the ass. The modding community isn't a utopia.
The issue here is that downloading a modder's work and just throwing it up on someone else's site - or worse, a platform - is a major, major no-no in the community. And it's still piracy, even if the mod is free. You can't just distribute people's stuff without permission; that's the essence of what copyright is about. It's not a strong or heavy handed case, but it is a case. And besides, this only EVER causes headaches since the mod author is completely in the dark about what platform it's on and what tools are being used. For example, if a modder only works with the Nexus, he probably opperates under the assumption you have the Nexus Mod Manager and all the tools that entails. If I take that mod and throw it up on Xbox's network, I - or the author, if I credit him and link to him - will be bombarded by questions and whining to which I have no answers and for which the readme doesn't account. Cause Xbox One has a specific set of specs (that are very different from 90% of PCs), extremely limited modding tools, I don't even know if you can access the freaking readmes. So it's not the whining, it's the nature of the whining. Their fine with complaints to which they either have answers or can deflect it to answers. They are not fine with being flamed for stuff that isn't their fault and questions they have no answers.
So to sum it all up: it's a extremely discourteous, technically still piracy, and absolutely guaranteed to cause nothing but trouble for everyone.
Edit: plus, all these untrue bug reports and such could seriously compromise the reputations of very responsible modders. Reputation is a big deal in modding and modders do a LOT to earn it. The massive influx of people complaining that the mod is broken or otherwise of poor quality could torpedo that.