By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Sony - Why Sony went the Neo route

Teeqoz said:
Sony wouldn't pay the costs for a die shrink though. AMD would, some of that cost might trickle down to Sony, but it's not like Sony would have to pay the hundreds of millions of dollars a die shrink costs.

uhm .. AMD certainly doesn't have that money to "waste"

if Sony insisted on AMD doing a 28nm -> 14/16nm die shrink "for free" after the probably planed 28nm -> 20nm one seemingly failed imo they would run a very high risk of bankrupting their APU supplier and in the aftermath of that losing out on hundreds of millions to billions of PS4 related profits



Around the Network

no i think it was their plan all along



Lafiel said:
Teeqoz said:
Sony wouldn't pay the costs for a die shrink though. AMD would, some of that cost might trickle down to Sony, but it's not like Sony would have to pay the hundreds of millions of dollars a die shrink costs.

uhm .. AMD certainly doesn't have that money to "waste"

if Sony insisted on AMD doing a 28nm -> 14/16nm die shrink "for free" after the probably planed 28nm -> 20nm one seemingly failed imo they would run a very high risk of bankrupting their APU supplier and in the aftermath of that losing out on hundreds of millions to billions of PS4 related profits

So you are telling me AMD aren't working towards a die shrink either way? I'm not saying AMD would do it "for free" but the op makes it sound like Sony would have to bank roll the entire thing.



Teeqoz said:
Lafiel said:

uhm .. AMD certainly doesn't have that money to "waste"

if Sony insisted on AMD doing a 28nm -> 14/16nm die shrink "for free" after the probably planed 28nm -> 20nm one seemingly failed imo they would run a very high risk of bankrupting their APU supplier and in the aftermath of that losing out on hundreds of millions to billions of PS4 related profits

So you are telling me AMD aren't working towards a die shrink either way? I'm not saying AMD would do it "for free" but the op makes it sound like Sony would have to bank roll the entire thing.

I'm certain when AMD and Sony made the contracts for the PS4 APU, they had plans for atleast one future die shrink, but after years of research all parties realized the 20nm process is bad for bigger chips like that - there is no cost reduction to be had.

The new 14/16nm process uses a different transistor design, so the whole chip has to be redesigned to be manufactured in that process and AMD didn't "port over" the architecture they used in the PS4 chip to this new node, they designed a new architecture from the ground up for it. But a same-speced 14nm chip with that new architecture won't run the games "coded to the metal" of the old PS4 as efficiently as the old architecture and shrinking the old architecture costs hundreds of millions of dollars.



Lafiel said:
Teeqoz said:

So you are telling me AMD aren't working towards a die shrink either way? I'm not saying AMD would do it "for free" but the op makes it sound like Sony would have to bank roll the entire thing.

I'm certain when AMD and Sony made the contracts for the PS4 APU, they had plans for atleast one future die shrink, but after years of research all parties realized the 20nm process is bad for bigger chips like that - there is no cost reduction to be had.

The new 14/16nm process uses a different transistor design, so the whole chip has to be redesigned to be manufactured in that process and AMD didn't "port over" the architecture they used in the PS4 chip to this new node, they designed a new architecture from the ground up for it. But a same-speced 14nm chip with that new architecture won't run the games "coded to the metal" of the old PS4 as efficiently as the old architecture and shrinking the old architecture costs hundreds of millions of dollars.

Fair enough.



Around the Network
Shadow1980 said:
If this is true, then it seems to put to rest the notion of upgrades to currently-existing platforms being the future of console releases instead of any more true "next-gen" systems being released, which was a preposterous theory in the first place.

However, if this works and the consoles sell well, this might become a standard going forward.