He used flawed logic then, that additional 5m wouldn't be a thing for Uncharted 4, it will sell all it can on PS4.

Though it will sell a LOT more than 8.66m even. The hype is just crazy even among people who never played the games.

3 games.... 21m + 5m = 26m / 3  = 8.67m ?

Am I doing it wrong?

Yes, why should sales of the remaster be added? It consists of three games and was sold separately on another console, if it was something like The Last Of Us or God Of War III where it was a remaster of one game I would agree, but there's a huge difference in perception and value for money with a remaster of three games which no doubt played a big factor in its sales, as did the mass bundling.

And with any remaster of a good game, there are people who double dip which goes to the other two remasters too that I mentioned, that doesn't contribute to franchise popularity, just overall sales.

This "average" wouldn't be applicable to Uncharted 4 unless its bundled with the other three games on PS5.

Because its the same game(s)?

"there's a huge difference in perception and value for money with a remaster of three games which no doubt played a big factor in its sales, as did the mass bundling."

Yeah true... but still alot of those are probably new users, that havnt played the games before either.

Uncharted 4 is still going over 10m copies sold imo.

3 million minimum i would say, biggest game of the year.

Was thinking 3 million first week and 5-6 million first month.

Yes it will, it has immense hype even among people I know who never played Uncharted games and they will be sure to check it out sooner than later.

Still that logic is flawed in my opinion. I bought the Uncharted PS4 bundle even though I had played it before and didn't want to buy it again but compared to the alternatives (BO III and SW BF) Uncharted just was the better choice. I believe I'm not the only one like this.

I highly doubt it would have had the same level of hype. People like to have an all in one package over split ones hence why FF X/X-2 HD sold better as a collection than individually. Uncharted 1 could have easily been ignored by the majority of double dippers, and 3 too to an extent. 2 has the biggest fanbase after all, but even then I don't think it would have sold as much as NDC.

Plus its not the same thing. They would be comparable if each Uncharted game was $40 or $50 like GOW III and TLOU. It wouldn't have sold even close to the same level as it did as NDC, Sony was smart to release it as a collection.

Agreed. Pretty obvious prediction though.

You can't group the original trilogy and the remaster together and say it's just 3 games xD.