By using this site, you agree to our Privacy Policy and our Terms of Use. Close

Forums - Nintendo - How the NX Controller will work, and why you will like it.

 

The NX Controller will be...

A game-changer 107 28.84%
 
The next Wii-Mote 32 8.63%
 
Stupid 53 14.29%
 
Weird 64 17.25%
 
A failure. 105 28.30%
 
Total:361

I don't get why people are very close-mind. The console is not even out and neither tried the controller, and already writting off. If by that people were, we will still be living in caverns. Thankfully, companies still have the audacy to try new things, whether they are successful or not.

Can't wait to try with my hands.



Proud to be the first cool Nintendo fan ever

Number ONE Zelda fan in the Universe

DKCTF didn't move consoles

Prediction: No Zelda HD for Wii U, quietly moved to the succesor

Predictions for Nintendo NX and Mobile


Around the Network
Wyrdness said:
Interesting theory, I don't think that's the controller though imo that role falls to the other patent of a gamepad like controller. The tech here though maybe implemented in it though as well as the handheld.

I think you combine the two patents.  One was about sticks and rolling bumpers, one was about a rounded touch screen.  Combine the two and you get the leaked image.  I believe there are two innovations going into the new device.

Also, I think this form of interface is both the home console and the portable.  I think the home screen will have a controller that mimics the portable, and the portable will run the same games at lower resolutions.



TheLastStarFighter said:
Wyrdness said:
Interesting theory, I don't think that's the controller though imo that role falls to the other patent of a gamepad like controller. The tech here though maybe implemented in it though as well as the handheld.

I think you combine the two patents.  One was about sticks and rolling bumpers, one was about a rounded touch screen.  Combine the two and you get the leaked image.  I believe there are two innovations going into the new device.

Also, I think this form of interface is both the home console and the portable.  I think the home screen will have a controller that mimics the portable, and the portable will run the same games at lower resolutions.

I can see that tbh, right now I'm picturing a gamepad using all this tech for the console and a N3DS like device employing the same tech for the handheld.



RolStoppable said:
TheLastStarFighter said:

Call me crazy, just don't call me late for dinner.

Let's talk a bit more about one point. The vertical setup is clearly inferior to a Wiimote because it's less ergonomical and has no buttons to work with. There's also no analog stick as a reference point to where the touchscreen buttons would be. Also, am I supposed to assume that this controller has a trigger like the B button of the Wiimote as well as a pointer?

Another thing is the emulation of a dual screen setup to emulate DS and 3DS games which you mentioned in the OP. You should realize that the form of the controller doesn't make it practical to hold it and that the control inputs below the two simulated screens would be crammed awkwardly together in addition to a lack of shoulder buttons.

I would view a rounded device as more ergonomical than a square one.  Either way, both devices look similar to a TV remote when held verticle, which was the inspiration for the Wii Mote.  The device is actually superior to the Wii mote because ith as an analogue stick that has force-feedback.  The device may have a trigger below, we don't know what the bottom looks like.  Going with the idea that the device has removable grips (concluding by combining the patent images with grips and leaked image without), there is no reason a trigger couldn't be below.

So, a Wii-mote has a d-pad, an a-button and a trigger, as well as the lesser-used 1 and 2 buttons below.  The NX device has an analogue stick wich by it's nature could handle both the d-pad funtions and the A button function.  If there is a trigger below, the device with it's touch screen far exceeds the level of interaction provided by the Wii-mote and in the very least matches it for backward compatibility or future casual titles.

The DS-simulation does look awkward, but it is merely a patent design.  I mention it solely to describe the potential plans and versatility of the device.  They could have further grip ad-ons.  I personally don't handheld game, but I can see Nintendo catering strongly to this market since it is presently the bulk of their sales.  I think this device is being designed to meet the needs of this market as well as the home consumer.



Wyrdness said:
TheLastStarFighter said:

I think you combine the two patents.  One was about sticks and rolling bumpers, one was about a rounded touch screen.  Combine the two and you get the leaked image.  I believe there are two innovations going into the new device.

Also, I think this form of interface is both the home console and the portable.  I think the home screen will have a controller that mimics the portable, and the portable will run the same games at lower resolutions.

I can see that tbh, right now I'm picturing a gamepad using all this tech for the console and a N3DS like device employing the same tech for the handheld.

And Nintendo tells square make one version and you get it on two systems.  And Square says ah, yeah, we're gonna bring DX and maybe FF to it.  And Nintendo says, wait, don't say anything yet!



Around the Network
Pavolink said:
I don't get why people are very close-mind. The console is not even out and neither tried the controller, and already writting off. If by that people were, we will still be living in caverns. Thankfully, companies still have the audacy to try new things, whether they are successful or not.

Can't wait to try with my hands.

I know!  I love a new style controller.  I love my XBox, but the interface is essentially the same as it was on the OG XBox.  When I picked up an SNES, half of the experience was the new interface in addition to the graphics.  This new NX device sounds facinating. 



TheLastStarFighter said:
collint0101 said:

I love Nintendo products but this look terrible. I can't play smash bros with this, I can't imagine trying to play smash bros with digital buttons and analog nubs and that's a huge downside for me because I'm a competive player. Then you have 3rd parties that would abandon this thing in a heart beat. If this is some kind of optional add on then yeah they should go for it let people see what it does but there needs to be a traditional controller bundled with every system

It has all of the interface third parties need, and more interface than a Wii-mote offered for Smash.  I think you'll need to give it a second look.

Wiimotes are terrible for smash. Saying it's a step up from that if like saying a Prius would be a better racecar than a mini van



collint0101 said:
TheLastStarFighter said:

It has all of the interface third parties need, and more interface than a Wii-mote offered for Smash.  I think you'll need to give it a second look.

Wiimotes are terrible for smash. Saying it's a step up from that if like saying a Prius would be a better racecar than a mini van

In your opinion.  A poster above is saying it's their go-to.



RolStoppable said:
TheLastStarFighter said:

I would view a rounded device as more ergonomical than a square one.  Either way, both devices look similar to a TV remote when held verticle, which was the inspiration for the Wii Mote.  The device is actually superior to the Wii mote because ith as an analogue stick that has force-feedback.  The device may have a trigger below, we don't know what the bottom looks like.  Going with the idea that the device has removable grips (concluding by combining the patent images with grips and leaked image without), there is no reason a trigger couldn't be below.

So, a Wii-mote has a d-pad, an a-button and a trigger, as well as the lesser-used 1 and 2 buttons below.  The NX device has an analogue stick wich by it's nature could handle both the d-pad funtions and the A button function.  If there is a trigger below, the device with it's touch screen far exceeds the level of interaction provided by the Wii-mote and in the very least matches it for backward compatibility or future casual titles.

The DS-simulation does look awkward, but it is merely a patent design.  I mention it solely to describe the potential plans and versatility of the device.  They could have further grip ad-ons.  I personally don't handheld game, but I can see Nintendo catering strongly to this market since it is presently the bulk of their sales.  I think this device is being designed to meet the needs of this market as well as the home consumer.

Neither of the analog sticks are in a good position when the controller is held vertically and that's a problem. The problem is that you are trying to cram additional functionality onto a controller which wasn't designed for such functionality.

Your entire line of thinking for such a controller can be summed up with the good old saying "can be used for anything, but is good for nothing." Nevermind that the thing has so many custom parts that it would drive up the costs significantly. I don't think Nintendo is going to go for something like that right after the 3DS (stereoscopic 3D components) and the Wii U (Gamepad technology) blew up in their faces.

Keep in mind I didn't come up with the device, I'm only suggesting what is likely.  And contrary to what you are saying, I do think Nintendo is going to release a device with an innovative/expesive input. We've seen the patents, we know their style.  They don't learn.

I think this could work much better than the Gamepad though.  I do think the device will be excellent for games I play, whether that be classic style Nintendo games or dual-analogue third party titles.  It may or may not be a lesser input for Wii-mote syled games, but I could live with that, I never really loved them.



Looks awful, will be expensive, why can't Nintendo make a good controller?