It not about the catch, it's the thrill of the chase. 

Disappointing reply but I already had my kick before I read the reply. 

Depending on the topic I usually think one of two things.

1: I expected this, I did post something good or debatable.
2: How could someone possibly respond to the nonsense I just typed.

Damm. Now I'll have to think twice about responding you XD

That used to be my drug, until I met certain sources. Nowadays my addiction comes in the form of Private Messages.

Damn you. I was trying to drink some coffee and almost spilled it out on the keyboard.

I can definitively relate to this second point. It hits too close home.

I love seeing that blue icon most of the times. I really like when someone acknowledges my opinion. Best part is when it comes as a surprise. I almost never expect for it to pop up.

How about now?

I actually smiled when I saw it.

I tend to be a bit cautious about these reply icons, because it could also mean someone has it in for me and really wants to win an argument.

Someone please respond to this so I can feel that euphoric pleasure once again.

Done.